The "G" Reviews--See the content keys for an explanation of the number.s
The Gilded Cage, by Lucinda Gray
Why this book is worth considering:
For an engrossing, girly, winter read by the fireplace, this is almost the perfect choice. It is fun, thrilling, romantic in a spooky Gothic sort of way, and relatively clean. While it is definitely mind candy, it is the kind that most parents would approve in the way they might approve of chick-flick movies. I would not give this to my younger teens, but for my older ones it's offers an eerily exciting trip back to the 19th century.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
Great literature this is not, and I am grateful to another reviewer who helped me see past my excitement to the so-so literary quality beneath. The plot is thin, the characters are mostly one-dimensional, and certain important plot-point questions are never clearly answered. The novel should have been much longer and more complex than it was for all of the tantalizing plot elements it started but never adequately finished. The author's strongest writing was near the end of the book when the protagonist experiences a real lunatic asylum...as a completely sane patient.
But is it a novel to give concerned parents much pause? Compared to most YA offerings these days, I don't think so. It does contain some violence, a couple of murders, some creepy-crawly scenes in a lunatic asylum, a "damn" here and there, and some stirrings of romance, but these were all depicted in a way that managed to be exciting and mysterious, yet mild. Parents should be aware that there is one passionate "groping" scene in the story, but there is no sex. Mild or not, though, particularly wary parents may want to give the book a quick skim before handing it to their teen.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens/ older teens/ all teens / no teens.
Author website: Because the author's name is a pseudonym, she does not have a website.
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
Why this book is worth considering:
For an engrossing, girly, winter read by the fireplace, this is almost the perfect choice. It is fun, thrilling, romantic in a spooky Gothic sort of way, and relatively clean. While it is definitely mind candy, it is the kind that most parents would approve in the way they might approve of chick-flick movies. I would not give this to my younger teens, but for my older ones it's offers an eerily exciting trip back to the 19th century.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
Great literature this is not, and I am grateful to another reviewer who helped me see past my excitement to the so-so literary quality beneath. The plot is thin, the characters are mostly one-dimensional, and certain important plot-point questions are never clearly answered. The novel should have been much longer and more complex than it was for all of the tantalizing plot elements it started but never adequately finished. The author's strongest writing was near the end of the book when the protagonist experiences a real lunatic asylum...as a completely sane patient.
But is it a novel to give concerned parents much pause? Compared to most YA offerings these days, I don't think so. It does contain some violence, a couple of murders, some creepy-crawly scenes in a lunatic asylum, a "damn" here and there, and some stirrings of romance, but these were all depicted in a way that managed to be exciting and mysterious, yet mild. Parents should be aware that there is one passionate "groping" scene in the story, but there is no sex. Mild or not, though, particularly wary parents may want to give the book a quick skim before handing it to their teen.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens/ older teens/ all teens / no teens.
Author website: Because the author's name is a pseudonym, she does not have a website.
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
Girls Like Us, by Gail Giles
*2015 PEN Center USA Literary Award Finalist; 2015 Schneider Family Book Award; 2014 National Book Awards; Longlist for Young People’s Literature; Booklist Editors’ Choice 2014, Fiction, Older Readers; 2015 Schneider Family Book Award Winner, Teen; YALSA’s 2015 Best Fiction for Young Adults; 2015 Amelia Bloomer Project List, Young Adult, Fiction; 2014 Cybils Awards Finalist, Young Adult Fiction; The New York Public Library, Best Books for Teens 2014!; Capitol Choices 2015*
Core themes: special needs young women, foster care upbringing, rape survival, finding friendships and family in unlikely places, being on one's own for the first time
Drugs/alcohol: Quincy's mother was a "crack ho"
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: Biddy had baby as a teen (see note in "violence/abuse")
Violence/abuse: Quincy's mother's boyfriend hit Quincy on the head with a brick during her childhood, which caused her both physical and mental damage; two fairly graphic descriptions of rape--one a group assault by teen boys, the other an adult criminal act in a dark alley (Note: It is important to note here that this violence is essential to the storyline and character development); Quincy's attacker carved "ho" onto her body
Vulgarities: 1, 3, 4
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Though this is at times a painful story--one of neglect, sexual violence, special needs struggles, and anger--it is also one of the most artful and moving YA novels I have ever read. Told in the voices of both Quincy and Biddy, the story is also one of healing, forgiveness, friendship, and family. Giles keeps her tale from being depressing or overly heavy through subtle humor, and her characterization is some of the best I have ever seen in any book for any age group. Be aware, though, that it is for mature teen readers, as Giles does not gloss over the violence that is at the heart of the story.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.gailgiles.com/Welcome.html
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*2015 PEN Center USA Literary Award Finalist; 2015 Schneider Family Book Award; 2014 National Book Awards; Longlist for Young People’s Literature; Booklist Editors’ Choice 2014, Fiction, Older Readers; 2015 Schneider Family Book Award Winner, Teen; YALSA’s 2015 Best Fiction for Young Adults; 2015 Amelia Bloomer Project List, Young Adult, Fiction; 2014 Cybils Awards Finalist, Young Adult Fiction; The New York Public Library, Best Books for Teens 2014!; Capitol Choices 2015*
Core themes: special needs young women, foster care upbringing, rape survival, finding friendships and family in unlikely places, being on one's own for the first time
Drugs/alcohol: Quincy's mother was a "crack ho"
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: Biddy had baby as a teen (see note in "violence/abuse")
Violence/abuse: Quincy's mother's boyfriend hit Quincy on the head with a brick during her childhood, which caused her both physical and mental damage; two fairly graphic descriptions of rape--one a group assault by teen boys, the other an adult criminal act in a dark alley (Note: It is important to note here that this violence is essential to the storyline and character development); Quincy's attacker carved "ho" onto her body
Vulgarities: 1, 3, 4
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Though this is at times a painful story--one of neglect, sexual violence, special needs struggles, and anger--it is also one of the most artful and moving YA novels I have ever read. Told in the voices of both Quincy and Biddy, the story is also one of healing, forgiveness, friendship, and family. Giles keeps her tale from being depressing or overly heavy through subtle humor, and her characterization is some of the best I have ever seen in any book for any age group. Be aware, though, that it is for mature teen readers, as Giles does not gloss over the violence that is at the heart of the story.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.gailgiles.com/Welcome.html
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
The Giver, by Lois Lowry (The Giver Quartet, book 1)
*1994 Newberry Medal, 1994 Regina Medal, 1996 William Allen White award, ALA listing for “Best Book for Young Adults”, “ALA Notable Children’s Book”, Boston Globe-Horn Book Honor Book, Booklist Editors’ Choice, School Library Journal Best Book of the Year; major motion picture released in August 2014
Core themes: conformity; the purpose of suffering; the use of technology to control the environment; finding a balance between protection and being able to make real choices
Drugs/alcohol: Everyone in the community is required to take pills to quell the “Stirrings” that begin at puberty. They also take pills for any pain or discomfort.
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: There is no romance because spouses are assigned and children are born to birth mothers (who are either artificially inseminated or have eggs implanted; it’s not clearly defined). As children grow into puberty, they begin taking pills to eliminate desire.
Violence/abuse: Children and the elderly are smacked with a “discipline wand” when it is deemed necessary. The elderly, the smaller of twins, and any babies that are deformed or otherwise non-conforming are all “released” (killed by an injection). The Giver provides violent and painful memories like breaking a leg, shooting an elephant and hacking off the tusks, fighting and death in a war, neglect, and hunger. (Excruciating hunger and starvation from large populations led to warfare which eventually convinced people in this community to create Sameness in an attempt to protect people from all pain, suffering, and discomfort.)
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry): * * * * *
Comments: This wonderful book invites young people to consider what a world would be like in which everyone was treated exactly the same and no one was allowed to feel anything meaningful in an attempt to protect all people from feeling any pain or discomfort. It’s also a book of love, courage, sacrifice, and beginning anew. The ending of the book is particularly powerful, as Jonas reaches the end of an exhausting journey and gazes in anticipation at what he hopes to be a new home.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: link seems to be broken, but give it a try -- http://www.loislowry.com/
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
*1994 Newberry Medal, 1994 Regina Medal, 1996 William Allen White award, ALA listing for “Best Book for Young Adults”, “ALA Notable Children’s Book”, Boston Globe-Horn Book Honor Book, Booklist Editors’ Choice, School Library Journal Best Book of the Year; major motion picture released in August 2014
Core themes: conformity; the purpose of suffering; the use of technology to control the environment; finding a balance between protection and being able to make real choices
Drugs/alcohol: Everyone in the community is required to take pills to quell the “Stirrings” that begin at puberty. They also take pills for any pain or discomfort.
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: There is no romance because spouses are assigned and children are born to birth mothers (who are either artificially inseminated or have eggs implanted; it’s not clearly defined). As children grow into puberty, they begin taking pills to eliminate desire.
Violence/abuse: Children and the elderly are smacked with a “discipline wand” when it is deemed necessary. The elderly, the smaller of twins, and any babies that are deformed or otherwise non-conforming are all “released” (killed by an injection). The Giver provides violent and painful memories like breaking a leg, shooting an elephant and hacking off the tusks, fighting and death in a war, neglect, and hunger. (Excruciating hunger and starvation from large populations led to warfare which eventually convinced people in this community to create Sameness in an attempt to protect people from all pain, suffering, and discomfort.)
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry): * * * * *
Comments: This wonderful book invites young people to consider what a world would be like in which everyone was treated exactly the same and no one was allowed to feel anything meaningful in an attempt to protect all people from feeling any pain or discomfort. It’s also a book of love, courage, sacrifice, and beginning anew. The ending of the book is particularly powerful, as Jonas reaches the end of an exhausting journey and gazes in anticipation at what he hopes to be a new home.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: link seems to be broken, but give it a try -- http://www.loislowry.com/
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
The Glass Sentence, by S.E. Grove (The Mapmakers Trilogy, #1)
Why this book is worth considering:
For a change I am reviewing a book with pleasure, because The Glass Sentence is absolutely brilliant. In fact, it deserves every accolade it receives. I am absolutely in awe of Grove's imagination, because the world she creates is unlike anything I have ever seen in a book and unlike anything I could have ever thought of myself, even a little. The only comparison I can make is Philip Pullman's trilogy His Dark Materials, which is also astonishingly original; in fact, I have seen several references to it as "perfect for fans of The Golden Compass." However, where that trilogy unabashedly glorifies sin and atheism, The Glass Sentence does not seem to be going in a similar direction. It is simply, dazzlingly brilliant.
Even better, it is free of mature/offensive content. There is no swearing, sex, romance (except a tiny hint at the end), underage drinking or drugs, abuse, or negative references to religion. There is a little violence and a lot of danger, but it is mild, exciting, and unlikely to disturb or frighten a teen. Parents, you may want to read this one yourself!
Finally, this is a great novel for readers who enjoy fantasy but are uncomfortable with magical elements. It is a fantasy, but it is set in our world and does not feature magical creatures or phenomena. Some of the world's elements do indeed seem magical, but that is only because the setting is a parallel universe that follows some natural laws that are not part of our universe.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
This novel is marketed to middle-grade readers, but it is appropriate for both teens and adults, too. In fact, some of the novel's concepts and world-building are so complex and original that I suspect that it is over the heads of some middle-grade children. I didn't even understand all of it, to be honest! Religious parents may also not like the fact that the only religious idea that has any strength in the novel is the protagonist's conviction that the "Fates" are in control of everything. There are vague references to the existence of organized religions, such as nuns walking through town, but they are respectful and subtle.
It is also important that I mention that I have not yet read the next two books in the series. I intend to, but until then, please be aware that the trilogy as a whole may be offensive in ways I do not yet know. The good news, though, is that this first book in the series can be read alone, if the next two are problematic to conservative parents.
Literary Artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: http://segrovebooks.com ; http://www.theglasssentence.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
- *New York Times Bestseller; IndieBound National Bestseller; Summer/Fall 2014 Indies Introduce New Voices Selection; A Top Ten Kid’s Next Selection; Publishers Weekly Flying Start; Washington Post Summer Book Club Selection; Junior Library Guild Selection; a Publishers Weekly’s Best Summer Reads; Amazon Summer 2014 Reading Selection; Amazon Top 20 Children’s/YA Book of 2014; ABC Best Book of 2014*
Why this book is worth considering:
For a change I am reviewing a book with pleasure, because The Glass Sentence is absolutely brilliant. In fact, it deserves every accolade it receives. I am absolutely in awe of Grove's imagination, because the world she creates is unlike anything I have ever seen in a book and unlike anything I could have ever thought of myself, even a little. The only comparison I can make is Philip Pullman's trilogy His Dark Materials, which is also astonishingly original; in fact, I have seen several references to it as "perfect for fans of The Golden Compass." However, where that trilogy unabashedly glorifies sin and atheism, The Glass Sentence does not seem to be going in a similar direction. It is simply, dazzlingly brilliant.
Even better, it is free of mature/offensive content. There is no swearing, sex, romance (except a tiny hint at the end), underage drinking or drugs, abuse, or negative references to religion. There is a little violence and a lot of danger, but it is mild, exciting, and unlikely to disturb or frighten a teen. Parents, you may want to read this one yourself!
Finally, this is a great novel for readers who enjoy fantasy but are uncomfortable with magical elements. It is a fantasy, but it is set in our world and does not feature magical creatures or phenomena. Some of the world's elements do indeed seem magical, but that is only because the setting is a parallel universe that follows some natural laws that are not part of our universe.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
This novel is marketed to middle-grade readers, but it is appropriate for both teens and adults, too. In fact, some of the novel's concepts and world-building are so complex and original that I suspect that it is over the heads of some middle-grade children. I didn't even understand all of it, to be honest! Religious parents may also not like the fact that the only religious idea that has any strength in the novel is the protagonist's conviction that the "Fates" are in control of everything. There are vague references to the existence of organized religions, such as nuns walking through town, but they are respectful and subtle.
It is also important that I mention that I have not yet read the next two books in the series. I intend to, but until then, please be aware that the trilogy as a whole may be offensive in ways I do not yet know. The good news, though, is that this first book in the series can be read alone, if the next two are problematic to conservative parents.
Literary Artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: http://segrovebooks.com ; http://www.theglasssentence.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
The Go-between, by Veronica Chambers
Why this book is worth considering:
The Go-Between tells the story of a teenager named Camilla del Valle. Her mother is a Mexican telenovela superstar, and her father is a very successful voice actor. Camilla is extremely wealthy, but when she moves from Mexico City to LA, the other kids assume she’s a scholarship kid from a low-income family. Camilla goes along with the story for fun and gets a crash course in the complexities of being a Mexican immigrant to America. This book challenges the stereotypes of Mexican immigrants but also points out the dangers in making assumptions about anybody else, even when their situation seems obvious. It’s not all serious, though -- the book features healthy family relationships with lots of good-natured teasing and a wry self-awareness from the protagonist. Although certain plot lines never seemed to develop while others felt worn-out, it’s overall an easy, light-hearted read that brings out some deeper themes.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
The central drama of this book is Camilla’s choice to lie to her friends. There is ambiguity about lying being right or wrong. The conclusion seems to be that small lies that make other people feel better are alright, but big lies are not, and all lies may have unintended harmful consequences. Although generally pretty clean, this book does contain some elements of teenage drinking, references to substance abuse, mild sexual interaction, and some profanity. Camilla goes out to a club with her friend and orders (but never drinks) one drink. Her friend later steals two of her mother’s prescription antidepressants and sells a fake story about her mother’s drug abuse to the press. Camilla ends this friendship over the incident. Camilla has a boyfriend, and there are references to kissing. At one point, Camilla’s parents mistakenly think she is pregnant and reassure her that although this is not what they wanted for her, they will figure it out together. Profanity mostly consists of b****, although there are some more isolated instances of other words, including f***. Religion does not play a prominent role in the book. It’s also worth noting that there is a brief description of gang violence in East LA.
Literary Artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: http://veronicachambers.com/
Reviewer: Emma Moore
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Godless, by Pete Hautman
*2004 National Book Award for Young People's Literature winner; 2005 Minnesota Book Award winner*
Core themes: adolescent rebellion against religion and forced corporate worship; what it means to be religious vs. truly a person of fatih; the power and influence we can unwittingly have over other people, especially if we are natural leaders
Drugs/alcohol: parents drink a gin and tonic
Religion/occult: parody of the creation story and other biblical writings prevalent throughout the book; parody of the Sermon on the Mount; profound irreverence for Catholicism and Christianity in general--example: Jason (protagonist) refers to the eucharistic host as "the little snack" of Catholic worshippers; very faithful, practicing, Catholic father indicates that "a lot of religions are perfectly good"; protagonist and friends create a "religion" of their own in which they "worship" a water tower and create their own "mass" and the elements that go with that (theology, scripture, sacraments, clergy, etc.); Jason, a Catholic teen who has secretly embraced atheism explores, questions, and ponders religion throughout the book. NOTE: Religious readers--especially Catholics--may find this novel disturbing to read, because the story is told in Jason's voice and honestly expresses his disbelief and struggles with religion.
Romance/sexuality: 1, 2
Violence/abuse: graphic, frightening scene of a non-fatal accident; reference to character getting a beating from father
Vulgarities: 1, 2, 3, 5, 6 Note: Sensitive religious readers should note that though blasphemous profanities are not used much, Jason's irreverence for Christianity is pervasive throughout the novel.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: As a religious person, I struggled with much of this novel. Some of it was painful to read, and I found the cliched portrayal of the well-meaning-but-idiotic youth group leader irritating and unnecessary. That said, I think there is room for an honest exploration of religion and faith in literature, and I think that is what the author is intending to do in his novel. While it does not support Christianity, especially Catholicism, the novel is well-done, fascinating, and often exciting, and it may be meaningful to teens who struggle with the same issues as Jason. Religious teen readers, however, should be very cautious if they are interested in reading this book. It may be worthwhile for some to read it in an effort to understand the struggles of non-believers; however, they might want to consider reading and discussing it with a trusted adult.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.petehautman.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*2004 National Book Award for Young People's Literature winner; 2005 Minnesota Book Award winner*
Core themes: adolescent rebellion against religion and forced corporate worship; what it means to be religious vs. truly a person of fatih; the power and influence we can unwittingly have over other people, especially if we are natural leaders
Drugs/alcohol: parents drink a gin and tonic
Religion/occult: parody of the creation story and other biblical writings prevalent throughout the book; parody of the Sermon on the Mount; profound irreverence for Catholicism and Christianity in general--example: Jason (protagonist) refers to the eucharistic host as "the little snack" of Catholic worshippers; very faithful, practicing, Catholic father indicates that "a lot of religions are perfectly good"; protagonist and friends create a "religion" of their own in which they "worship" a water tower and create their own "mass" and the elements that go with that (theology, scripture, sacraments, clergy, etc.); Jason, a Catholic teen who has secretly embraced atheism explores, questions, and ponders religion throughout the book. NOTE: Religious readers--especially Catholics--may find this novel disturbing to read, because the story is told in Jason's voice and honestly expresses his disbelief and struggles with religion.
Romance/sexuality: 1, 2
Violence/abuse: graphic, frightening scene of a non-fatal accident; reference to character getting a beating from father
Vulgarities: 1, 2, 3, 5, 6 Note: Sensitive religious readers should note that though blasphemous profanities are not used much, Jason's irreverence for Christianity is pervasive throughout the novel.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: As a religious person, I struggled with much of this novel. Some of it was painful to read, and I found the cliched portrayal of the well-meaning-but-idiotic youth group leader irritating and unnecessary. That said, I think there is room for an honest exploration of religion and faith in literature, and I think that is what the author is intending to do in his novel. While it does not support Christianity, especially Catholicism, the novel is well-done, fascinating, and often exciting, and it may be meaningful to teens who struggle with the same issues as Jason. Religious teen readers, however, should be very cautious if they are interested in reading this book. It may be worthwhile for some to read it in an effort to understand the struggles of non-believers; however, they might want to consider reading and discussing it with a trusted adult.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.petehautman.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Going Vintage, by Lindsey Leavitt
*2014 Texas Tayshas Reading List*
Core themes: coming-of-age, first-love, relying too much on modern technology and social-networking to the detriment of living in the moment
Drugs/alcohol: none –- speculation of whether certain kids at school are drug dealers but no actual drug or alcohol use
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: 1 –- mild, an instance of a teen pregnancy from the past
Violence/abuse: none
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Going Vintage is a funny, enjoyable read with an interesting plot that carried through to the end. The protagonist, Mallory, has a great voice and is a character you can root for as she navigates her way through a dicey break-up and subsequent lifestyle change. I also liked the way the family cared for each other through disagreements and the discovery of certain secrets. A great read for when you are tired of all the drama in your life and want inspiration to make a change.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://lindseyleavitt.com/
Reviewer: Annika Holland
*2014 Texas Tayshas Reading List*
Core themes: coming-of-age, first-love, relying too much on modern technology and social-networking to the detriment of living in the moment
Drugs/alcohol: none –- speculation of whether certain kids at school are drug dealers but no actual drug or alcohol use
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: 1 –- mild, an instance of a teen pregnancy from the past
Violence/abuse: none
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Going Vintage is a funny, enjoyable read with an interesting plot that carried through to the end. The protagonist, Mallory, has a great voice and is a character you can root for as she navigates her way through a dicey break-up and subsequent lifestyle change. I also liked the way the family cared for each other through disagreements and the discovery of certain secrets. A great read for when you are tired of all the drama in your life and want inspiration to make a change.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://lindseyleavitt.com/
Reviewer: Annika Holland
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Gone, by Michael Grant (Gone series, book #1)
Core themes: conflicting value systems when the rules of society are removed; self-preservation; survival of the fittest; sacrifice
Drugs/alcohol: beer drinking by one teen as a means of coping with his actions
Religion/occult: speculation about whether God caused what has happened; prayer to God for help in life/death situations; one character says a Hail Mary and the Prayer to St. Michael the Archangel in a life and death situation
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: instances of physical bullying, intimidation, multiple deaths from attacks by coyotes, fire and neglect. Multiple instances of slaps in the face, punching, some gunfire, being burned, injuries from falling objects. Descriptions aren’t gratuitous but are more semi-graphic if it involves a main character
Vulgarities: 1, 3, 4 –- minimal/infrequent. Several instances of a bully making fun of an autistic child by calling him a retard
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Gone revolves around a character named Sam after everyone older than 14 years disappears within a 20-mile radius on the coast of California. He is the one everybody looks to for guidance and answers. As the reluctant leader, he does his best to maintain order and find out what has happened. When an anti-hero shows up, we get a solid glimpse into the true character of Sam. He is smart, sensitive toward others, makes the right choices even when they are difficult, and does it all with some wry humor on the side. There is a sense of anticipation with the book as each chapter has a time on it which refers to how long Sam has until he turns 15 and "blinks out.” Part sci-fi, part mystery, part teen romance, this is a cleverly plotted page turner--a modern day Lord of the Flies.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens /all teens/ no teens. Note: A younger teen could read this but it would depend a lot on their sensitivity toward violence between children.
Author website: http://www.themichaelgrant.com/
Reviewer: Sabrina Holland
Core themes: conflicting value systems when the rules of society are removed; self-preservation; survival of the fittest; sacrifice
Drugs/alcohol: beer drinking by one teen as a means of coping with his actions
Religion/occult: speculation about whether God caused what has happened; prayer to God for help in life/death situations; one character says a Hail Mary and the Prayer to St. Michael the Archangel in a life and death situation
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: instances of physical bullying, intimidation, multiple deaths from attacks by coyotes, fire and neglect. Multiple instances of slaps in the face, punching, some gunfire, being burned, injuries from falling objects. Descriptions aren’t gratuitous but are more semi-graphic if it involves a main character
Vulgarities: 1, 3, 4 –- minimal/infrequent. Several instances of a bully making fun of an autistic child by calling him a retard
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Gone revolves around a character named Sam after everyone older than 14 years disappears within a 20-mile radius on the coast of California. He is the one everybody looks to for guidance and answers. As the reluctant leader, he does his best to maintain order and find out what has happened. When an anti-hero shows up, we get a solid glimpse into the true character of Sam. He is smart, sensitive toward others, makes the right choices even when they are difficult, and does it all with some wry humor on the side. There is a sense of anticipation with the book as each chapter has a time on it which refers to how long Sam has until he turns 15 and "blinks out.” Part sci-fi, part mystery, part teen romance, this is a cleverly plotted page turner--a modern day Lord of the Flies.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens /all teens/ no teens. Note: A younger teen could read this but it would depend a lot on their sensitivity toward violence between children.
Author website: http://www.themichaelgrant.com/
Reviewer: Sabrina Holland
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
The Good Braider, by Terry Farish
*A YALSA/ American Library Association Best Book for Young Adults, American Library Association’s 2014 Books for the College Bound and Lifelong Learner, Winner of The Boston Authors Club Young Reader Award, A School Library Journal Best Book of the Year, The Lupine Award presented by the Maine Library Association, A Bank Street College of Education Best Book of the Year, Georgia Peach Book Award Finalist, New Hampshire Literary Award for a Young Adult Book, Goodreads Best Multicultural Young Adult Book selection, Taysha Reading List in Texas*
Core themes: immigration; effects of war on noncombatants (women and children); African conflicts and African-Americans; deaths of family members due to malnutrition, war, and old age
Drugs/alcohol: a large dose of a herb is taken to prevent a baby after a rape
Religion/occult: Viola’s faith and that of her family, who are all Christian, is a main reason they are attacked and persecuted by the Muslim soldiers; they often turn to God for strength
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: Viola is raped repeatedly by a soldier; soldiers often kill people for no apparent reason or for fickle reasons; Viola’s mother abuses her, according to American standards (and is arrested for it)
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This is a beautifully written book that puts the lives of those escaping Sudan’s war and the struggles they face (physical and psychological in Sudan and while escaping to America and adjusting to cultural differences when they arrive) into focus. It will probably appeal mostly to young women. Because of the rapes, it would be best for teens who already know about such crimes, though the language describing the acts is not graphic. A short appendix describes the situation in Sudan and South Sudan and helps to put the entire book into perspective.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://terryfarish.com/
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
*A YALSA/ American Library Association Best Book for Young Adults, American Library Association’s 2014 Books for the College Bound and Lifelong Learner, Winner of The Boston Authors Club Young Reader Award, A School Library Journal Best Book of the Year, The Lupine Award presented by the Maine Library Association, A Bank Street College of Education Best Book of the Year, Georgia Peach Book Award Finalist, New Hampshire Literary Award for a Young Adult Book, Goodreads Best Multicultural Young Adult Book selection, Taysha Reading List in Texas*
Core themes: immigration; effects of war on noncombatants (women and children); African conflicts and African-Americans; deaths of family members due to malnutrition, war, and old age
Drugs/alcohol: a large dose of a herb is taken to prevent a baby after a rape
Religion/occult: Viola’s faith and that of her family, who are all Christian, is a main reason they are attacked and persecuted by the Muslim soldiers; they often turn to God for strength
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: Viola is raped repeatedly by a soldier; soldiers often kill people for no apparent reason or for fickle reasons; Viola’s mother abuses her, according to American standards (and is arrested for it)
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This is a beautifully written book that puts the lives of those escaping Sudan’s war and the struggles they face (physical and psychological in Sudan and while escaping to America and adjusting to cultural differences when they arrive) into focus. It will probably appeal mostly to young women. Because of the rapes, it would be best for teens who already know about such crimes, though the language describing the acts is not graphic. A short appendix describes the situation in Sudan and South Sudan and helps to put the entire book into perspective.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://terryfarish.com/
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
Goodbye Days, by Jeff Zentner
*nominated for the Carnegie Medal; longlisted for the UKLA Award; longlisted for the Southern Book Prize; ALA Best Fiction for Young Adults Top Ten pick; Capitol Choices Noteworthy Book; Teen Choice Award nominee; A Whitney Award finalist; AML YA Book Award winner; Indie Next pick; Oklahoma Sequoyah Masterlist pick; Illinois Lincoln Award nominee; North Carolina Young Adult Book Award Nominee; Maryland Black-Eyed Susan Book Award nominee; Louisiana Teen Readers’ Choice nominee; Texas Library Association TAYSHA pick; Florida Teen Reads pick; Goodreads Choice Award Semifinalist; Epic Reads Shimmy Award Semifinalist; Publishers Weekly Noteworthy Second Novel of 2017; Paste Magazine Top 10 Most Anticipated YA Novel for 2017; Barnes and Noble Most Anticipated Sophomore YA Novel for 2017; PopCrush Most Anticipated YA Novel for March 2017*
Why this book is worth considering:
One has to wonder how Zentner found the emotional depth and insight necessary to write a novel with such heavy themes as death, grief, healing, crime, love, and hate. All of these themes are central to Goodbye Days and never once stray from their course. Writing well about even one of them is a challenge, yet Zentner manages to juggle them all and catch them one by one in the end. His characters are vivid and believable, his understanding of human nature is deep, and his plotting is smooth and compelling. And while this is a tragic story, it is not a “tragedy,” for through its pages we follow the characters not only through their grief in the wake of three boys’ deaths, but we also watch them recover their hope and begin their paths to healing. For those looking for examples of strong YA writing, here is one, for few authors could tell such a sad, painful story this well. In addition, for those seeking stories that might help teens process their own experiences with death or understand the dangers of distracted driving, Goodbye Days may be a good choice..
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
As well-written as it is in the literary sense, this is not a novel to choose lightly. It contains a lot of mature and sometimes disturbing content that teen readers may not be ready for--or that may be offensive in regard to its unorthodox, sometimes godless religious and philosophical themes. Because of its pervasive focus on death and grief, the story is unusually sad and even depressing. For some teens it may be confusing without adult guidance. In addition, the novel contains a fair amount of swearing that ranges from mild to blasphemous, as well as vulgar, crude, “locker room” talk. Drinking and drug use is present; however, it is minor and contributes to the plot. While the story doesn’t contain a lot of violence either, it revolves around a violent incident that results in the deaths of three teen boys. Plus, there is a plot thread that involves past child abuse, and one character is physically assaulted by an adult.
The story contains no sex or lustful kissing; however, romance, love, and physical desire do play an important role in the story, and one character’s mother is said to have slept with many men when she was a minor. An adult character is gay and shares the news he has married, and another character comes out as gay, though without romance. They are both given unequivocal support by other characters.
As concerning as all these issues may be for some parents and teens, none of them are as important or potentially problematic as the treatment of religion, worldview, and philosophy in the novel. More than most YA authors do (in my experience), Zentner handles this aspect of the novel with a measure of respect for both religious and atheist readers by showing how characters with different views about God handle their grief. Even so, remaining completely neutral on such weighty issues would be impossible for any author, and Zentner is no exception. A detailed discussion of all the ways in which he reveals his own worldview would be too long for me to detail, but three things stood out to me:
Literary Artistry (quality of writing): * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: https://www.jeffzentnerbooks.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*nominated for the Carnegie Medal; longlisted for the UKLA Award; longlisted for the Southern Book Prize; ALA Best Fiction for Young Adults Top Ten pick; Capitol Choices Noteworthy Book; Teen Choice Award nominee; A Whitney Award finalist; AML YA Book Award winner; Indie Next pick; Oklahoma Sequoyah Masterlist pick; Illinois Lincoln Award nominee; North Carolina Young Adult Book Award Nominee; Maryland Black-Eyed Susan Book Award nominee; Louisiana Teen Readers’ Choice nominee; Texas Library Association TAYSHA pick; Florida Teen Reads pick; Goodreads Choice Award Semifinalist; Epic Reads Shimmy Award Semifinalist; Publishers Weekly Noteworthy Second Novel of 2017; Paste Magazine Top 10 Most Anticipated YA Novel for 2017; Barnes and Noble Most Anticipated Sophomore YA Novel for 2017; PopCrush Most Anticipated YA Novel for March 2017*
Why this book is worth considering:
One has to wonder how Zentner found the emotional depth and insight necessary to write a novel with such heavy themes as death, grief, healing, crime, love, and hate. All of these themes are central to Goodbye Days and never once stray from their course. Writing well about even one of them is a challenge, yet Zentner manages to juggle them all and catch them one by one in the end. His characters are vivid and believable, his understanding of human nature is deep, and his plotting is smooth and compelling. And while this is a tragic story, it is not a “tragedy,” for through its pages we follow the characters not only through their grief in the wake of three boys’ deaths, but we also watch them recover their hope and begin their paths to healing. For those looking for examples of strong YA writing, here is one, for few authors could tell such a sad, painful story this well. In addition, for those seeking stories that might help teens process their own experiences with death or understand the dangers of distracted driving, Goodbye Days may be a good choice..
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
As well-written as it is in the literary sense, this is not a novel to choose lightly. It contains a lot of mature and sometimes disturbing content that teen readers may not be ready for--or that may be offensive in regard to its unorthodox, sometimes godless religious and philosophical themes. Because of its pervasive focus on death and grief, the story is unusually sad and even depressing. For some teens it may be confusing without adult guidance. In addition, the novel contains a fair amount of swearing that ranges from mild to blasphemous, as well as vulgar, crude, “locker room” talk. Drinking and drug use is present; however, it is minor and contributes to the plot. While the story doesn’t contain a lot of violence either, it revolves around a violent incident that results in the deaths of three teen boys. Plus, there is a plot thread that involves past child abuse, and one character is physically assaulted by an adult.
The story contains no sex or lustful kissing; however, romance, love, and physical desire do play an important role in the story, and one character’s mother is said to have slept with many men when she was a minor. An adult character is gay and shares the news he has married, and another character comes out as gay, though without romance. They are both given unequivocal support by other characters.
As concerning as all these issues may be for some parents and teens, none of them are as important or potentially problematic as the treatment of religion, worldview, and philosophy in the novel. More than most YA authors do (in my experience), Zentner handles this aspect of the novel with a measure of respect for both religious and atheist readers by showing how characters with different views about God handle their grief. Even so, remaining completely neutral on such weighty issues would be impossible for any author, and Zentner is no exception. A detailed discussion of all the ways in which he reveals his own worldview would be too long for me to detail, but three things stood out to me:
- Even though Tennessee law says that texting while driving is illegal, the teen driver who responded to the text while driving (and died as a result) was presented as a victim from beginning to end. Nowhere in the book did any character—not even the lawyers—propose that he bore any responsibility for the accident. I was both perplexed and disturbed by this, since this seemed to promote the idea that others are to blame for the consequences of our actions, instead of ourselves.
- An important character muses that occurrences that seem ordained or that seem to have a cause are only perceived that way by our minds. In reality, the happenings around us and in the universe are probably just random and chaotic. This may be upsetting or confusing to religious readers who believe in a divine order.
- Finally, and perhaps most illuminating to me, the author seemed to convey the viewpoint that people should be loved and honored more than God and that God answers to us--as if we can control and stand up to God as His equal. To me, this message was so strong and so important for parents to know about that I think a quote is important here:
- Nana Betsy looks skyward. “Blake, honey, if you can hear me, listen real good now.” She faces me and swallows hard, and when she speaks, the tremor is gone from her voice and it envelops me like a down quilt. “…I love you more than I love God himself. So if he’s got a problem with anything, he can talk to me…”
Literary Artistry (quality of writing): * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: https://www.jeffzentnerbooks.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Goodbye, Rebel Blue, by Shelley Coriell
*2016 Oklahoma Sequoyah Award*
Core themes: the importance of being honest with others and true to oneself; the power of our own choices and how they are most important in carving our life's path, forming our characters, and discovering our destinies (though fate and God may have a hand, too)
Drugs/alcohol: protagonist smokes some
Religion/occult: characters contemplate what happens to souls after death, as well as the question of whether fate, human will, or a higher power controls our destinies; a memorial service ("celebration of life") is held in a church; vague religious references pepper the story, because a supporting character is from a large Catholic family (for example, his little brother tells Rebel Blue that she'll go to hell if she swears, and their home contains statues of saints); Rebel Blue contemplates different beliefs about God but affirms that she doesn't believe in an afterlife (though she is clearly searching and open)
Romance/sexuality: 1 Note: There is also a brief reference to how Rebel was conceived as the result of a one-night stand and thus doesn't know her father's identity.
Violence/abuse: second-hand account of how high-school girl, Kennedy Green, died; Rebel Blue's friend, Macey, has a history of cutting herself
Vulgarities: 1, 2, 3, 4 Note: #4 was used only once; the others were occasional.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Although the novel is a bit flawed with some stereotypes, contrivances and predictability, I gave it four stars for its overall quality and thematic depth. I also thought it excellent for its vivid characterization and use of powerful voice. Rebel Blue is a brilliantly conceived character, and I felt like her development was both realistic and meaningful. The novel is also an excellent study of the power we have to make our own way in life and to choose to do good or evil--not to succumb to the destructive belief that we are victims and pawns of chance. Religious readers may find Rebel's agnostism/atheism a little troublesome, but she is respectful enough of those who believe otherwise. Also, the questions she ponders in her efforts to grow and find meaning in Kennedy Green's bucket list are universal.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.shelleycoriell.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*2016 Oklahoma Sequoyah Award*
Core themes: the importance of being honest with others and true to oneself; the power of our own choices and how they are most important in carving our life's path, forming our characters, and discovering our destinies (though fate and God may have a hand, too)
Drugs/alcohol: protagonist smokes some
Religion/occult: characters contemplate what happens to souls after death, as well as the question of whether fate, human will, or a higher power controls our destinies; a memorial service ("celebration of life") is held in a church; vague religious references pepper the story, because a supporting character is from a large Catholic family (for example, his little brother tells Rebel Blue that she'll go to hell if she swears, and their home contains statues of saints); Rebel Blue contemplates different beliefs about God but affirms that she doesn't believe in an afterlife (though she is clearly searching and open)
Romance/sexuality: 1 Note: There is also a brief reference to how Rebel was conceived as the result of a one-night stand and thus doesn't know her father's identity.
Violence/abuse: second-hand account of how high-school girl, Kennedy Green, died; Rebel Blue's friend, Macey, has a history of cutting herself
Vulgarities: 1, 2, 3, 4 Note: #4 was used only once; the others were occasional.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Although the novel is a bit flawed with some stereotypes, contrivances and predictability, I gave it four stars for its overall quality and thematic depth. I also thought it excellent for its vivid characterization and use of powerful voice. Rebel Blue is a brilliantly conceived character, and I felt like her development was both realistic and meaningful. The novel is also an excellent study of the power we have to make our own way in life and to choose to do good or evil--not to succumb to the destructive belief that we are victims and pawns of chance. Religious readers may find Rebel's agnostism/atheism a little troublesome, but she is respectful enough of those who believe otherwise. Also, the questions she ponders in her efforts to grow and find meaning in Kennedy Green's bucket list are universal.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.shelleycoriell.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Gossip Girl, by Cecily von Ziegesar (Gossip Girl series, book 1)
*made into TV show 2007*
Core themes: high school relationships of all kinds, the freedom wealth gives from limitations, gossip and consequences, hedonism in all its glitter, coping strategies of wealthy neglected kids, contrast between haves-and-have nots, class-boundary crossing; sexual awakening and hedonistic indulgence of it among wealthy teens
Drugs/alcohol: underage drinking and drugs (pot, cigarettes), game called Buck Naked (about drinking and being unclothed)
Religion/occult: not carefully noted in this review but generally an absent subject
Sexuality: 1, 2, 3, 5, 6 Comments: Though the numbers above may be shocking, they cannot begin to truly encapsulate the sexual content in this book. Gossip Girl is full of sexual content, covering nearly every sexual act or thought known to teens and stopping just short of graphic, in-your-face sex.
Vulgarities: pervasive and spanned the gamut
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This novel gave me the feeling that the author and publisher got together to create a series that pushed the boundaries far beyond what they knew was acceptable and then sat back to see what would happen. What happened was a bestseller series and TV show that sound like a teen-friendly Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous. The lack of adult backlash, I believe, is due to the fact that most adults have not read the books and therefore don’t know what they’re really all about. In actuality, Gossip Girl is the one of the most (perhaps the most) morally bankrupt fiction marketed to young adults. All of the language, drugs, smoking, drinking and sex—and all these things fill the book--are gratuitous. It’s as if the author went out of her way to include every type of inappropriate situation, other than graphic sex, that she could think of. I have read some terrible books in my life, but this is one of the worst. And please, if you think I am exaggerating, I urge you to read the book yourself before you approve of it for your teen.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: none
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*made into TV show 2007*
Core themes: high school relationships of all kinds, the freedom wealth gives from limitations, gossip and consequences, hedonism in all its glitter, coping strategies of wealthy neglected kids, contrast between haves-and-have nots, class-boundary crossing; sexual awakening and hedonistic indulgence of it among wealthy teens
Drugs/alcohol: underage drinking and drugs (pot, cigarettes), game called Buck Naked (about drinking and being unclothed)
Religion/occult: not carefully noted in this review but generally an absent subject
Sexuality: 1, 2, 3, 5, 6 Comments: Though the numbers above may be shocking, they cannot begin to truly encapsulate the sexual content in this book. Gossip Girl is full of sexual content, covering nearly every sexual act or thought known to teens and stopping just short of graphic, in-your-face sex.
Vulgarities: pervasive and spanned the gamut
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This novel gave me the feeling that the author and publisher got together to create a series that pushed the boundaries far beyond what they knew was acceptable and then sat back to see what would happen. What happened was a bestseller series and TV show that sound like a teen-friendly Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous. The lack of adult backlash, I believe, is due to the fact that most adults have not read the books and therefore don’t know what they’re really all about. In actuality, Gossip Girl is the one of the most (perhaps the most) morally bankrupt fiction marketed to young adults. All of the language, drugs, smoking, drinking and sex—and all these things fill the book--are gratuitous. It’s as if the author went out of her way to include every type of inappropriate situation, other than graphic sex, that she could think of. I have read some terrible books in my life, but this is one of the worst. And please, if you think I am exaggerating, I urge you to read the book yourself before you approve of it for your teen.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: none
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
A Great and Terrible Beauty, by Libba Bray (Gemma Doyle Trilogy, #1)
*2005-06 Texas Tayshas Reading List; A New York Times Bestseller; A Publishers Weekly Bestseller; A Book Sense Bestseller; BBYA (ALA/YALSA Best Book for Young Adults); Iowa High School Book Award; Garden State Teen Book Award; Pennsylvania Young Reader’s Choice Award*
Core themes: relations between Victorian social classes, rebellion vs. propriety, experiments in the occult, sexual awakening, Victorian parent-child relationships, the worth and expectations of girls in Victorian society and the effects on their emotions, finding oneself and winning freedom vs. obeying customs and submitting to expectations
Drugs/alcohol: father takes opium to ease grief (common drug in Victorian times), character steals non-consecrated communion wine on a dare (which turns out to be the priest’s private stash of whiskey), underage drinking of wine
Religion/occult: not carefully noted in this review, but occult events are the driving force of the book
Romance/sexuality: 1, 2, 6
Violence/abuse: chaotic suicide scene by desperate mother while daughter watches, visions of evil phantom and images of the occult, character cuts herself frequently on arms to relieve emotional pain, girls get naked to hunt and sacrifice a deer as "payment” to evil spirits, fairly graphic description of killing the deer
Vulgarities: 1, 5
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This was a fascinating novel that I could hardly put down, beautiful and exciting; however, because of the strong sexual and occult themes, it would not be a book I could suggest in good conscience to a teenager.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: I have chosen two recommendations--on based on age-appropriateness and the other based on my feelings about the book.
Author website: http://libbabray.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*2005-06 Texas Tayshas Reading List; A New York Times Bestseller; A Publishers Weekly Bestseller; A Book Sense Bestseller; BBYA (ALA/YALSA Best Book for Young Adults); Iowa High School Book Award; Garden State Teen Book Award; Pennsylvania Young Reader’s Choice Award*
Core themes: relations between Victorian social classes, rebellion vs. propriety, experiments in the occult, sexual awakening, Victorian parent-child relationships, the worth and expectations of girls in Victorian society and the effects on their emotions, finding oneself and winning freedom vs. obeying customs and submitting to expectations
Drugs/alcohol: father takes opium to ease grief (common drug in Victorian times), character steals non-consecrated communion wine on a dare (which turns out to be the priest’s private stash of whiskey), underage drinking of wine
Religion/occult: not carefully noted in this review, but occult events are the driving force of the book
Romance/sexuality: 1, 2, 6
Violence/abuse: chaotic suicide scene by desperate mother while daughter watches, visions of evil phantom and images of the occult, character cuts herself frequently on arms to relieve emotional pain, girls get naked to hunt and sacrifice a deer as "payment” to evil spirits, fairly graphic description of killing the deer
Vulgarities: 1, 5
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This was a fascinating novel that I could hardly put down, beautiful and exciting; however, because of the strong sexual and occult themes, it would not be a book I could suggest in good conscience to a teenager.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: I have chosen two recommendations--on based on age-appropriateness and the other based on my feelings about the book.
Author website: http://libbabray.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
Greenglass House (Greenglass House series #1)
*New York Times Bestseller; National Book Award Nominee; Winner of the Edgar Award for Best Juvenile Mystery; Nebula/Andre Norton Award Nominee*
Why this book is worth considering:
My favorite type of children's book is the kind of middle-grade novel that feels timeless, almost from another world yet delightfully, firmly in ours. This is that kind of book. Plus, it's fresh, original, unusual, fun, and complex. Even though the protagonist is only 12, which makes this a middle-grade novel, I am reviewing it because most of the characters are older and because the novel is complex enough to appeal to a wide range of ages. Adopted children might particularly enjoy the novel, because adoption is an important theme and plot element of the story. If your pre-teen or teen enjoys complex mysteries and quirky characters, this novel is an excellent choice. Plus, there are four more in the series!
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
Honestly, I can't come up with a reason this would be inappropriate for anyone, unless you are strongly opposed to ghosts. The novel does have a ghostly character; however, it is kept very lighthearted. This is not a paranormal mystery; it's just another quirky addition to the quirky cast of characters. Being a middle-grade novel, of course there is no swearing, except for once. An adult character says, "Good God" as an expletive. Some readers will not consider this swearing, but others will, so I felt it worth mentioning.
Literary Artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: https://clockworkfoundry.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*New York Times Bestseller; National Book Award Nominee; Winner of the Edgar Award for Best Juvenile Mystery; Nebula/Andre Norton Award Nominee*
Why this book is worth considering:
My favorite type of children's book is the kind of middle-grade novel that feels timeless, almost from another world yet delightfully, firmly in ours. This is that kind of book. Plus, it's fresh, original, unusual, fun, and complex. Even though the protagonist is only 12, which makes this a middle-grade novel, I am reviewing it because most of the characters are older and because the novel is complex enough to appeal to a wide range of ages. Adopted children might particularly enjoy the novel, because adoption is an important theme and plot element of the story. If your pre-teen or teen enjoys complex mysteries and quirky characters, this novel is an excellent choice. Plus, there are four more in the series!
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
Honestly, I can't come up with a reason this would be inappropriate for anyone, unless you are strongly opposed to ghosts. The novel does have a ghostly character; however, it is kept very lighthearted. This is not a paranormal mystery; it's just another quirky addition to the quirky cast of characters. Being a middle-grade novel, of course there is no swearing, except for once. An adult character says, "Good God" as an expletive. Some readers will not consider this swearing, but others will, so I felt it worth mentioning.
Literary Artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: https://clockworkfoundry.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
The Grimm Legacy, by Polly Shulman
*2011 Children's Choices; 2011 Texas Lone Star Reading List; ALA Best Fiction for Young Adults 2011; IRA Children's Choices 2011, Advanced Readers; Children's Book Committee Bank Street College of Education Children's Choices - Best Books of 2011, Fantasy, ages 9-12; School Library Journal Best Books 2010: Fiction;Smithsonian, Notable Books for Children 2010; Mythopoeic Fantasy Award for Children's Literature 2011, Finalist; Nominated for Readers Awards in 14 states: Arkansas, Connecticut, Georgia, Maryland, Missouri, New Hampshire, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, and Vermont; Western Australian Young Readers Book Award 2014, Nominee; Leserpreis–die besten Buecher 2010 (German award), Shortlist; Grand Prix de l’Imaginaire (French award) 2015, Finalist*
Core themes: the struggle for integrity, fantasy become real, battle of good vs. evil, identifying one's true friends
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: pervasive fairy-tale content, including magical items, people, and beings (both good and evil)
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: several villains who seek to inflict harm, such as an evil woman who transforms people into dolls and keeps them as part of a collection; some evil, magical objects
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I found this to be a delightful story. It may not be great literature, but sometimes it's nice to have just good, clean, suspenseful entertainment. If you are okay with magical objects and magical humans being a part of our world (fairy-tale characters come to life), I highly recommend this book as a nice break from the glut of angst-ridden, dark stories being published today.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens /all teens/ no teens.
Author website: http://www.pollyshulman.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*2011 Children's Choices; 2011 Texas Lone Star Reading List; ALA Best Fiction for Young Adults 2011; IRA Children's Choices 2011, Advanced Readers; Children's Book Committee Bank Street College of Education Children's Choices - Best Books of 2011, Fantasy, ages 9-12; School Library Journal Best Books 2010: Fiction;Smithsonian, Notable Books for Children 2010; Mythopoeic Fantasy Award for Children's Literature 2011, Finalist; Nominated for Readers Awards in 14 states: Arkansas, Connecticut, Georgia, Maryland, Missouri, New Hampshire, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, and Vermont; Western Australian Young Readers Book Award 2014, Nominee; Leserpreis–die besten Buecher 2010 (German award), Shortlist; Grand Prix de l’Imaginaire (French award) 2015, Finalist*
Core themes: the struggle for integrity, fantasy become real, battle of good vs. evil, identifying one's true friends
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: pervasive fairy-tale content, including magical items, people, and beings (both good and evil)
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: several villains who seek to inflict harm, such as an evil woman who transforms people into dolls and keeps them as part of a collection; some evil, magical objects
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I found this to be a delightful story. It may not be great literature, but sometimes it's nice to have just good, clean, suspenseful entertainment. If you are okay with magical objects and magical humans being a part of our world (fairy-tale characters come to life), I highly recommend this book as a nice break from the glut of angst-ridden, dark stories being published today.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens /all teens/ no teens.
Author website: http://www.pollyshulman.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist