The "C" Reviews--See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
The Cardturner by Louis Sachar
Core themes: familial relationships, influence of the past on present relationships, overcoming physical obstacles
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: Some conversations about whether after death, we continue on as an idea.
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: none
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I enjoyed The Cardturner very much. While the idea of a YA novel about bridge may seem an odd choice, Sachar astutely weaves the bridge-playing in with the story of Alton, a teenage boy who is bored and looking for direction. Enter his rich, blind great-uncle who is need of a cardturner for his weekly bridge games. Trapp is a man of few words, but over time Alton builds up a bond with him and learns to play bridge in the process. I highly recommend this book for anyone but most especially for those who play games like bridge or chess competitively.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.louissacher.com
Reviewer: Annika Holland
Core themes: familial relationships, influence of the past on present relationships, overcoming physical obstacles
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: Some conversations about whether after death, we continue on as an idea.
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: none
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I enjoyed The Cardturner very much. While the idea of a YA novel about bridge may seem an odd choice, Sachar astutely weaves the bridge-playing in with the story of Alton, a teenage boy who is bored and looking for direction. Enter his rich, blind great-uncle who is need of a cardturner for his weekly bridge games. Trapp is a man of few words, but over time Alton builds up a bond with him and learns to play bridge in the process. I highly recommend this book for anyone but most especially for those who play games like bridge or chess competitively.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.louissacher.com
Reviewer: Annika Holland
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
The Castle Behind Thorns, by Merrie Haskell
Core themes: forgiveness and emotional healing, survival, finding the courage to start life anew, friendship and family
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: Although this novel is a fairy tale, the author uses the religious piety of medieval France as a conduit for the magic that propels the story forward. Rather than keeping religion and fairy-tale magic separate, she uses real saints as the "magicians." They are not only responsible for the magic that is fundamental to the plot, they also appear late in the novel to the protagonists and talk to them about how they have used magic to help and to give advice to Perotte on how to forgive (it is important to note that neither God nor Christian teaching are referenced in this advice). Religious readers, especially those who venerate saints, may be disturbed by the way Christian teaching against the use of magic is ignored. Magic is also the power by which Perotte, dead for 25 years, comes back to life and by which Saint Melor's heart begins beating again and by which he begins talking to the protagonists. Finally, it should be noted that the most pious character in the novel (who prays, says the rosary, and does other pious acts) is also the villain.
Romance/sexuality: none
Violence/abuse: protagonists are harmed by magical thorns; several knights are killed by the magical thorns; mild account of how Perotte was murdered by poisoned slippers; mild account of how saint had hand and foot cut off
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Although this is a middle-grade novel that I intended to read only for fun, I soon realized that the protagonists were young teens and may appeal to young teen readers. The story is clearly influenced by "Sleeping Beauty," but it is not a retelling. It is a fairy tale with some new twists I have not seen before, particularly the intertwining of Catholic piety with fairy-tale magic. This was a twist I felt was in very poor taste, but I didn't have the sense that disrespect was meant to religious readers. It is meant to be a fun story with a positive message about renewal and forgiveness--and it is fun and interesting with enough action to keep young readers engaged.
My impression was that the religious elements were meant to help ground the story in the real time and place of medieval France, instead of the "Once upon a time" realm of the storybook world. Recognizing that, however, and putting aside my irritation with the way the author mixed Christianity and magic, I still didn't enjoy the novel as much as I expected. Some of the plot elements struck me as odd, even for a fairy tale, and the writing itself felt off to me at times with odd wording in the narrative and bits of dialogue that didn't ring true. Considering that the jacket blurbs gushed about the book, one reviewer even raving about the "gorgeous language," I'm not sure if it is me or the jacket blurbs that you should pay attention to more. My general feeling, though, is that if you are not sensitive to the misrepresentation of Christianity in stories, this is at least a safe choice for your teen. If you are, however, I'd pick another fantasy. Narnia, anyone?
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.merriehaskell.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
Core themes: forgiveness and emotional healing, survival, finding the courage to start life anew, friendship and family
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: Although this novel is a fairy tale, the author uses the religious piety of medieval France as a conduit for the magic that propels the story forward. Rather than keeping religion and fairy-tale magic separate, she uses real saints as the "magicians." They are not only responsible for the magic that is fundamental to the plot, they also appear late in the novel to the protagonists and talk to them about how they have used magic to help and to give advice to Perotte on how to forgive (it is important to note that neither God nor Christian teaching are referenced in this advice). Religious readers, especially those who venerate saints, may be disturbed by the way Christian teaching against the use of magic is ignored. Magic is also the power by which Perotte, dead for 25 years, comes back to life and by which Saint Melor's heart begins beating again and by which he begins talking to the protagonists. Finally, it should be noted that the most pious character in the novel (who prays, says the rosary, and does other pious acts) is also the villain.
Romance/sexuality: none
Violence/abuse: protagonists are harmed by magical thorns; several knights are killed by the magical thorns; mild account of how Perotte was murdered by poisoned slippers; mild account of how saint had hand and foot cut off
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Although this is a middle-grade novel that I intended to read only for fun, I soon realized that the protagonists were young teens and may appeal to young teen readers. The story is clearly influenced by "Sleeping Beauty," but it is not a retelling. It is a fairy tale with some new twists I have not seen before, particularly the intertwining of Catholic piety with fairy-tale magic. This was a twist I felt was in very poor taste, but I didn't have the sense that disrespect was meant to religious readers. It is meant to be a fun story with a positive message about renewal and forgiveness--and it is fun and interesting with enough action to keep young readers engaged.
My impression was that the religious elements were meant to help ground the story in the real time and place of medieval France, instead of the "Once upon a time" realm of the storybook world. Recognizing that, however, and putting aside my irritation with the way the author mixed Christianity and magic, I still didn't enjoy the novel as much as I expected. Some of the plot elements struck me as odd, even for a fairy tale, and the writing itself felt off to me at times with odd wording in the narrative and bits of dialogue that didn't ring true. Considering that the jacket blurbs gushed about the book, one reviewer even raving about the "gorgeous language," I'm not sure if it is me or the jacket blurbs that you should pay attention to more. My general feeling, though, is that if you are not sensitive to the misrepresentation of Christianity in stories, this is at least a safe choice for your teen. If you are, however, I'd pick another fantasy. Narnia, anyone?
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.merriehaskell.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Cast Two Shadows: The American Revolution in the South, by Ann Rinaldi (a Great Episodes book)
Core themes: Revolutionary War; race; slavery; identity; growing up
Drugs/alcohol: Caroline’s grandmother gives her a “leaf” to make her sleep. A Cherokee chief made Caroline’s grandmother’s husband drunk so he could kill him. Jimmy drinks from a flask. There are drunken soldiers as well.
Religion/occult: Caroline’s grandmother (a slave) makes conjure bags. Before the hanging of her friend, Caroline would have said God was good, but afterward she doesn’t seem certain. (“God isn’t here anymore.”) The family is Presbyterian. Caroline admired the words of a Quaker reprinted in the paper. She and her grandmother do help those they meet on the journey in part because God requires it.
Romance/sexuality: 1, 2, 4 Note: Number 4 is noted because the protagonist is the daughter of a white master and his slave.)
Violence/abuse: Set during the Revolutionary War, this book reports much of the carnage of the war in the South (massacres, executions, desecration of bodies, scalpings, etc). Most of it is reported rather than described, but Caroline does watch the hanging of her 14-year-old friend. Caroline is slapped by her grandmother once. Caroline fears she killed a sick woman by suffocating her when trying to silence her as enemy soldiers sought them, though both her brother and her grandmother believe it was the illness. The British threaten to whip their slaves. Caroline sets her own house on fire as they escape.
Vulgarities: 1
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I’ve selected all teens for this book, but I think it’s important that the reader understand what is involved in fathering a child, as Caroline’s identity and her father’s relationships with the women in his life is a major theme of the novel. In many ways, Caroline’s grandmother is at the heart of the novel, teaching Caroline how to live with hardship and sorrow, “You jus’ make it, is all.” At another time she tells Caroline that growing up means learning to do what must be done regardless of your own desires.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: none available
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
Core themes: Revolutionary War; race; slavery; identity; growing up
Drugs/alcohol: Caroline’s grandmother gives her a “leaf” to make her sleep. A Cherokee chief made Caroline’s grandmother’s husband drunk so he could kill him. Jimmy drinks from a flask. There are drunken soldiers as well.
Religion/occult: Caroline’s grandmother (a slave) makes conjure bags. Before the hanging of her friend, Caroline would have said God was good, but afterward she doesn’t seem certain. (“God isn’t here anymore.”) The family is Presbyterian. Caroline admired the words of a Quaker reprinted in the paper. She and her grandmother do help those they meet on the journey in part because God requires it.
Romance/sexuality: 1, 2, 4 Note: Number 4 is noted because the protagonist is the daughter of a white master and his slave.)
Violence/abuse: Set during the Revolutionary War, this book reports much of the carnage of the war in the South (massacres, executions, desecration of bodies, scalpings, etc). Most of it is reported rather than described, but Caroline does watch the hanging of her 14-year-old friend. Caroline is slapped by her grandmother once. Caroline fears she killed a sick woman by suffocating her when trying to silence her as enemy soldiers sought them, though both her brother and her grandmother believe it was the illness. The British threaten to whip their slaves. Caroline sets her own house on fire as they escape.
Vulgarities: 1
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I’ve selected all teens for this book, but I think it’s important that the reader understand what is involved in fathering a child, as Caroline’s identity and her father’s relationships with the women in his life is a major theme of the novel. In many ways, Caroline’s grandmother is at the heart of the novel, teaching Caroline how to live with hardship and sorrow, “You jus’ make it, is all.” At another time she tells Caroline that growing up means learning to do what must be done regardless of your own desires.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: none available
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
Catch You Later, Traitor, by Avi
Why this book is worth considering:
It isn't often that I unequivocally recommend a book, but I can do so with this one. I didn't expect to enjoy Traitor much, to be honest. Although I highly respect Newbery-award winner Avi as a writer, the book jacket made me doubt that it would be my cup of tea. But it was. Not only does the story address a period of American history that few young people know about--the fear of Communistic takeover in the 1950s--it was also fast-moving and exciting while remaining real and meaningful. Avi does a fantastic job conveying the overhyped anxieties and suspicions of many Americans during this era, as well as the dangers some Americans faced when they were suspected of communistic activities. Though Traitor features a boy protagonist and appears to be marketed to boys, it is actually a excellent historical fiction read for both boys and girls.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
This is one of the few books that did not raise red flags for me. One reason is that it is marketed as a middle-grade novel, although the protagonist is about thirteen years old. Since middle-grade novels are published under different standards from YA literature, they don't frequently contain content of concern to most parents. However, it is possible that very conservative parents may not like the fact that some of the adults smoke and that the story presents the concepts of communism and socialism in a relatively neutral manner.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.avi-writer.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
Why this book is worth considering:
It isn't often that I unequivocally recommend a book, but I can do so with this one. I didn't expect to enjoy Traitor much, to be honest. Although I highly respect Newbery-award winner Avi as a writer, the book jacket made me doubt that it would be my cup of tea. But it was. Not only does the story address a period of American history that few young people know about--the fear of Communistic takeover in the 1950s--it was also fast-moving and exciting while remaining real and meaningful. Avi does a fantastic job conveying the overhyped anxieties and suspicions of many Americans during this era, as well as the dangers some Americans faced when they were suspected of communistic activities. Though Traitor features a boy protagonist and appears to be marketed to boys, it is actually a excellent historical fiction read for both boys and girls.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
This is one of the few books that did not raise red flags for me. One reason is that it is marketed as a middle-grade novel, although the protagonist is about thirteen years old. Since middle-grade novels are published under different standards from YA literature, they don't frequently contain content of concern to most parents. However, it is possible that very conservative parents may not like the fact that some of the adults smoke and that the story presents the concepts of communism and socialism in a relatively neutral manner.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.avi-writer.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Chalice, by Robin McKinley
Core themes: abuse of power, duty, healing, not fitting in, love of one’s land, doubting oneself and one’s abilities, rituals dealing with different aspects of life, the need to educate oneself to fulfill responsibilities, not understanding the nuances of a role for which one was not prepared
Drugs/alcohol: references mostly to wine (sometimes mead) throughout the book in ritual use; a couple of mentions of drinking mead during stressful times; one reference to being drunk or drugged at a party
Religion/occult: the book is full of references, given that the main characters are part of a group, called the Circle, that control and are trying to heal the land through magical means and rituals; also, one of the main characters was studying to become an elemental priest, so this is mentioned numerous times as a major part of his identity
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: brief mention (no details) of an execution due to capital offense; one scene towards the end of a duel to settle mastership that is not very graphic; one brief suggestion of suicide that could easily be overlooked (the main character is tied to the land and cannot leave its boundaries but suggests she might try out of despair); and a brief, internal questioning by the main character of whether or not the Overlord would try to have her killed, which is immediately disregarded as an option of potential outcomes
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: The occult references are more like a pagan community before Christianity. It’s a way of life, and there is a ritual for just about everything, but it is not put in juxtaposition to Christianity. There are vague references to outrageous parties and desire for and abuse of power in the past that have had a negative impact on the land that the main characters are trying to heal. Everything is explored through the perspective of the main character, and while some topics could be considered controversial, they are dealt with cerebrally and not graphically. The main characters do not shirk their duties or responsibilities, although they may fail in their efforts through no fault of their own.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: http://www.robinmckinley.com/
Reviewer: Aimee Miranda
Core themes: abuse of power, duty, healing, not fitting in, love of one’s land, doubting oneself and one’s abilities, rituals dealing with different aspects of life, the need to educate oneself to fulfill responsibilities, not understanding the nuances of a role for which one was not prepared
Drugs/alcohol: references mostly to wine (sometimes mead) throughout the book in ritual use; a couple of mentions of drinking mead during stressful times; one reference to being drunk or drugged at a party
Religion/occult: the book is full of references, given that the main characters are part of a group, called the Circle, that control and are trying to heal the land through magical means and rituals; also, one of the main characters was studying to become an elemental priest, so this is mentioned numerous times as a major part of his identity
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: brief mention (no details) of an execution due to capital offense; one scene towards the end of a duel to settle mastership that is not very graphic; one brief suggestion of suicide that could easily be overlooked (the main character is tied to the land and cannot leave its boundaries but suggests she might try out of despair); and a brief, internal questioning by the main character of whether or not the Overlord would try to have her killed, which is immediately disregarded as an option of potential outcomes
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: The occult references are more like a pagan community before Christianity. It’s a way of life, and there is a ritual for just about everything, but it is not put in juxtaposition to Christianity. There are vague references to outrageous parties and desire for and abuse of power in the past that have had a negative impact on the land that the main characters are trying to heal. Everything is explored through the perspective of the main character, and while some topics could be considered controversial, they are dealt with cerebrally and not graphically. The main characters do not shirk their duties or responsibilities, although they may fail in their efforts through no fault of their own.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: http://www.robinmckinley.com/
Reviewer: Aimee Miranda
Challenger Deep, by Neal Shusterman
*National Book Award Winner; National Book Award Finalist; A Top 10 book on YALSA’s 2016 Best Fiction for Young Adults list; Boston Globe/Horn Book Honor Book; Horn Book Fanfare Best Book of the Year; Kirkus Best Book of the Year; Publishers Weekly Best Book of the Year; School Library Journal Best Book of the Year; New York Public Library Best Book of the Year for Teens; Chicago Public Library Best Teen Book of the Year; ALA Best Fiction for Young Adults nominee; Bookpage Best Teen Book of the Year; 2017 Abraham Lincoln Award Nominee*
Why this book is worth considering:
Few YA novels have the literary quality that this one does. If I was to compile a list of YA novels worth studying in a class, in fact, this one would be a candidate. A profound and moving journey into mental illness through the mind of one teenage boy, Challenger Deep allows the reader to experience vicariously what it can be like to go insane--and then to begin the ascent to recovery. The fact that Shusterman is writing from personal experience makes this novel even more powerful. Teens will not find much offensive material here, either. There are very few swear words, no sexual content, and no recreational drug or alcohol use (though there is a great deal of the prescription variety by necessity). Religion does not play much of a role, either, although God is discussed a few times and not always in a positive light. It is important to understand, however, that these religious comments are made in the context of insanity and should therefore not be construed as offensive content, in my opinion. For a teen ready for a mature, literary novel, Challenger Deep is a good choice.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
As beautifully written as this novel may be, I can't say I really enjoyed it. I'm not sure it is even meant to be enjoyed but more experienced for the value of better understanding what it is like to be mentally ill. This is not an entertaining novel but a thought-provoking and sometimes difficult one; therefore, it will not appeal to or be appropriate for some teens, especially those who are emotionally sensitive to the subject of mental illness. Part of the reason the novel is difficult to read is that the story flips between the real world and a kind of parallel dream/fantasy world playing out in Caden's mind as he journeys into mental illness and recovers. Teens who begin the story understanding the purpose of this dream-world story will have an easier time understanding the novel. I did not understand until I was about halfway through, so I found the novel difficult to read until that point. Mature themes and some violence and frightening images in the dream-world are the primary reasons parents might want to skim through the book before approving it for their teens.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: Younger teens may be able to handle this novel, too, and it is mostly pretty clean. I am specifying "older teens," however, because of the challenging content and mature themes.
Author website: http://www.storyman.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*National Book Award Winner; National Book Award Finalist; A Top 10 book on YALSA’s 2016 Best Fiction for Young Adults list; Boston Globe/Horn Book Honor Book; Horn Book Fanfare Best Book of the Year; Kirkus Best Book of the Year; Publishers Weekly Best Book of the Year; School Library Journal Best Book of the Year; New York Public Library Best Book of the Year for Teens; Chicago Public Library Best Teen Book of the Year; ALA Best Fiction for Young Adults nominee; Bookpage Best Teen Book of the Year; 2017 Abraham Lincoln Award Nominee*
Why this book is worth considering:
Few YA novels have the literary quality that this one does. If I was to compile a list of YA novels worth studying in a class, in fact, this one would be a candidate. A profound and moving journey into mental illness through the mind of one teenage boy, Challenger Deep allows the reader to experience vicariously what it can be like to go insane--and then to begin the ascent to recovery. The fact that Shusterman is writing from personal experience makes this novel even more powerful. Teens will not find much offensive material here, either. There are very few swear words, no sexual content, and no recreational drug or alcohol use (though there is a great deal of the prescription variety by necessity). Religion does not play much of a role, either, although God is discussed a few times and not always in a positive light. It is important to understand, however, that these religious comments are made in the context of insanity and should therefore not be construed as offensive content, in my opinion. For a teen ready for a mature, literary novel, Challenger Deep is a good choice.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
As beautifully written as this novel may be, I can't say I really enjoyed it. I'm not sure it is even meant to be enjoyed but more experienced for the value of better understanding what it is like to be mentally ill. This is not an entertaining novel but a thought-provoking and sometimes difficult one; therefore, it will not appeal to or be appropriate for some teens, especially those who are emotionally sensitive to the subject of mental illness. Part of the reason the novel is difficult to read is that the story flips between the real world and a kind of parallel dream/fantasy world playing out in Caden's mind as he journeys into mental illness and recovers. Teens who begin the story understanding the purpose of this dream-world story will have an easier time understanding the novel. I did not understand until I was about halfway through, so I found the novel difficult to read until that point. Mature themes and some violence and frightening images in the dream-world are the primary reasons parents might want to skim through the book before approving it for their teens.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: Younger teens may be able to handle this novel, too, and it is mostly pretty clean. I am specifying "older teens," however, because of the challenging content and mature themes.
Author website: http://www.storyman.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Champion, by Marie Lu (Legend Trilogy, book 3)
Core themes: the sacrifice of one for the needs of the many; Big Questions--What is right? Who decides what is good and what is bad?;
Drugs/alcohol: medicinal hallucinogenic cigarettes; occasional drinking of vodka or wine
Religion/occult: June prays when she is desperate.
Romance/sexuality: 1, 2, 5
Violence/abuse: description of a murder; violent battles, including some hand-to-hand combat; blackmail (threatening of loved ones)
Vulgarities: 1, 3, 5
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: There’s a lot of violence in this book as the fighting escalates toward the culmination of the series. Quite a few main characters are killed in the fighting. There are some big questions about governments and compromises, but mostly this book seemed to be about action and June and Day’s relationship.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://marielubooks.tumblr.com/ / Series website: http://www.legendtheseries.com/
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
Core themes: the sacrifice of one for the needs of the many; Big Questions--What is right? Who decides what is good and what is bad?;
Drugs/alcohol: medicinal hallucinogenic cigarettes; occasional drinking of vodka or wine
Religion/occult: June prays when she is desperate.
Romance/sexuality: 1, 2, 5
Violence/abuse: description of a murder; violent battles, including some hand-to-hand combat; blackmail (threatening of loved ones)
Vulgarities: 1, 3, 5
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: There’s a lot of violence in this book as the fighting escalates toward the culmination of the series. Quite a few main characters are killed in the fighting. There are some big questions about governments and compromises, but mostly this book seemed to be about action and June and Day’s relationship.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://marielubooks.tumblr.com/ / Series website: http://www.legendtheseries.com/
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
Chasing Secrets, by Gennifer Choldenko
Why this book is worth considering:
As a historical middle grade novel, this is as about as squeaky clean as it can get. There is no swearing, no issues with religion, no passionate romance, no drug abuse. Lizzie, the protagonist, is 13, so she does experience the flush of first crush and some confusing feelings about boys. The subject matter, too, is compelling for a young teen reader, because it's about a little-known subject: turn-of-the-century San Francisco. Adding to the interesting setting is the fearsome subject of the plague that threatened the city at that time. Choldenko tells her story well, too. Lizzie's voice is appealing, and her adventures are both attention-keeping and instructive at the same time. While I wouldn't call the story nail-biting, which might be considered unfortunate by those looking for big thrills, it was definitely worth reading and recommending to young teens looking for an engrossing read. It might be particularly compelling to those interested in the efforts of women to enter the medical profession during a time when it was generally unacceptable. Choldenko also manages to incorporate the themes of social class relations and Euro-/Chinese-American race relations at this time in history. Because of the feminist and class/race relations themes, parents might want to take advantage of them as discussion launch points.
Why it may not be right for your teen:
I have to think hard about this one, because I really have no complaints about it. It wasn't my favorite story, but it was a good one. Possibly the only things that might concern parents is the mild (very mild) romantic elements and the moderate violence. By violence I mean a medical emergency at the beginning, a death near the end (mostly non-graphic), and a nighttime bandit attack that ends well for Lizzie.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens/ no teens.
Author Website: http://www.gennifercholdenko.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
Why this book is worth considering:
As a historical middle grade novel, this is as about as squeaky clean as it can get. There is no swearing, no issues with religion, no passionate romance, no drug abuse. Lizzie, the protagonist, is 13, so she does experience the flush of first crush and some confusing feelings about boys. The subject matter, too, is compelling for a young teen reader, because it's about a little-known subject: turn-of-the-century San Francisco. Adding to the interesting setting is the fearsome subject of the plague that threatened the city at that time. Choldenko tells her story well, too. Lizzie's voice is appealing, and her adventures are both attention-keeping and instructive at the same time. While I wouldn't call the story nail-biting, which might be considered unfortunate by those looking for big thrills, it was definitely worth reading and recommending to young teens looking for an engrossing read. It might be particularly compelling to those interested in the efforts of women to enter the medical profession during a time when it was generally unacceptable. Choldenko also manages to incorporate the themes of social class relations and Euro-/Chinese-American race relations at this time in history. Because of the feminist and class/race relations themes, parents might want to take advantage of them as discussion launch points.
Why it may not be right for your teen:
I have to think hard about this one, because I really have no complaints about it. It wasn't my favorite story, but it was a good one. Possibly the only things that might concern parents is the mild (very mild) romantic elements and the moderate violence. By violence I mean a medical emergency at the beginning, a death near the end (mostly non-graphic), and a nighttime bandit attack that ends well for Lizzie.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens/ no teens.
Author Website: http://www.gennifercholdenko.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Chinese Cinderella: The True Story of an Unwanted Daughter, by Adeline
Yen Mah
Core themes: child abuse (emotional and physical), Chinese culture, arranged marriage, self-worth
Drugs/alcohol: grandfather smokes a pipe, perhaps wine with a meal
Religion/occult: references to both Christianity (specifically Catholic) and Buddhism, but faith itself plays relatively small role in the book; the author happily attends Catholic schools and is described praying on multiple occasions, sometimes in a chapel; Catholic nuns are kind but depicted as unwilling or unable to improve the author’s situation in any meaningful way; Buddhist funerals for the author’s grandparents but the event is overshadowed by her grief, so it is not described extensively
Romance/sexuality: none; fear of an arranged marriage but no descriptions
Violence/abuse: physical abuse (several times) by stepmother (of the author and of another daughter); foot binding of the author’s grandmother; physical abuse of the author by her siblings (mainly brothers); presence of soldiers and some fear during World War II; abandonment: the author was forgotten on her first day of school, the author’s father and step-mother leave her in a school in a town imminently threatened by Communist troops, and other times; repeated verbal abuse by the author’s stepmother and siblings, especially the half-siblings, though her father also whips her; emotional abuse–-the author’s father does not remember her name or her birthdate; withholding food as punishment; abuse of elderly parents (mainly through control and dishonoring them rather than physical); child slavery--at a local hotel a child is described sitting outside wearing a sign that she is “for sale”
Vulgarities: derogatory Chinese language; otherwise, none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This book is an adaptation of Falling Leaves by the same author for young adults, and it is very similar to the adult title. Because her mother dies soon after her birth, the author is viewed as bad luck. Her father’s subsequent remarriage and the birth of two more children (with five from the first marriage) lead to repeated abuse. Though sometimes this abuse is physical, it is more often emotional. While it can be difficult to read of her experiences, the author’s goal is to reach out to others who may be suffering or have suffered as she did and to encourage them to realize that their worth is not dependent on what they learn from their abusers. She had marvelous relationships with her aunt and her grandfather, who loved and supported her, giving her the encouragement and determination to succeed.
The author also shows great respect for the Chinese culture and language. Because she remembers life during World War II and the advent of Communism, the book provides some documentation of that time from the point of view of a child.
I was personally disappointed in the behavior of some of the Catholic nuns the author encounters in her schools. She never describes them in a derogatory way or accuses them of collaborating with her parents, but it is clear that they were unable or unwilling to help her when her family was obviously mistreating her. It is perhaps not surprising given the time period and the Chinese culture, but I’d like to think professed Catholics would react differently today.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://adelineyenmah.com/
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
Yen Mah
Core themes: child abuse (emotional and physical), Chinese culture, arranged marriage, self-worth
Drugs/alcohol: grandfather smokes a pipe, perhaps wine with a meal
Religion/occult: references to both Christianity (specifically Catholic) and Buddhism, but faith itself plays relatively small role in the book; the author happily attends Catholic schools and is described praying on multiple occasions, sometimes in a chapel; Catholic nuns are kind but depicted as unwilling or unable to improve the author’s situation in any meaningful way; Buddhist funerals for the author’s grandparents but the event is overshadowed by her grief, so it is not described extensively
Romance/sexuality: none; fear of an arranged marriage but no descriptions
Violence/abuse: physical abuse (several times) by stepmother (of the author and of another daughter); foot binding of the author’s grandmother; physical abuse of the author by her siblings (mainly brothers); presence of soldiers and some fear during World War II; abandonment: the author was forgotten on her first day of school, the author’s father and step-mother leave her in a school in a town imminently threatened by Communist troops, and other times; repeated verbal abuse by the author’s stepmother and siblings, especially the half-siblings, though her father also whips her; emotional abuse–-the author’s father does not remember her name or her birthdate; withholding food as punishment; abuse of elderly parents (mainly through control and dishonoring them rather than physical); child slavery--at a local hotel a child is described sitting outside wearing a sign that she is “for sale”
Vulgarities: derogatory Chinese language; otherwise, none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This book is an adaptation of Falling Leaves by the same author for young adults, and it is very similar to the adult title. Because her mother dies soon after her birth, the author is viewed as bad luck. Her father’s subsequent remarriage and the birth of two more children (with five from the first marriage) lead to repeated abuse. Though sometimes this abuse is physical, it is more often emotional. While it can be difficult to read of her experiences, the author’s goal is to reach out to others who may be suffering or have suffered as she did and to encourage them to realize that their worth is not dependent on what they learn from their abusers. She had marvelous relationships with her aunt and her grandfather, who loved and supported her, giving her the encouragement and determination to succeed.
The author also shows great respect for the Chinese culture and language. Because she remembers life during World War II and the advent of Communism, the book provides some documentation of that time from the point of view of a child.
I was personally disappointed in the behavior of some of the Catholic nuns the author encounters in her schools. She never describes them in a derogatory way or accuses them of collaborating with her parents, but it is clear that they were unable or unwilling to help her when her family was obviously mistreating her. It is perhaps not surprising given the time period and the Chinese culture, but I’d like to think professed Catholics would react differently today.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://adelineyenmah.com/
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
Chronicles of Kazam, by Jasper Fforde
See the reviews for the following books in the series:
The Last Dragonslayer, book 1
The Song of the Quarkbeast, book 2
The Eye of Zoltar, book 3
See the reviews for the following books in the series:
The Last Dragonslayer, book 1
The Song of the Quarkbeast, book 2
The Eye of Zoltar, book 3
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
City of Bones, by Cassandra Clare (Mortal Instruments series)Note: This Note: This review covers books #1-5.
*made into movie 2013*
Core themes: supernatural battle of good vs. evil, intolerance, search for truth, parental/family love and sacrifice
Drugs/alcohol: none in the first book – some wine and tequila drinking in book 5
Religion/occult: some occult occurrences of tarot card usage and reading tea leaves; a cast of villains including different types of demons and “downworlders.” Downworlders are half human/half something else - like a werewolf, vampire, witch etc... The power of the Shadowhunters (ones who hunt demons) is said to have come from the Angel Raziel. Some Shadowhunters choose to believe in God, others do not. There is nothing that glorifies or encourages belief in the occult and its tools. In subsequent books there are more occult practices, including the raising of demons for evil purposes.
Romance/sexuality: 1, 5
Violence/abuse: killing of demons using knives and swords; werewolves battling vampires and zombie types. There is bloodshed, but it is not overly gratuitous or graphic. In later books there are some occult practices, including blood sacrifice and people bitten by vampires, and some more slightly graphic battle scenes.
Vulgarities: 1,3 -- infrequent
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: If you took certain plot points of Harry Potter and crammed it together with Twilight you might get something similar to this series. Overall, this was an okay story if you like supernatural fiction. The trouble I find with this type of fiction is that every author has to explain where the different entities come from and why they are good or bad. This leads to a liberal mixing of ancient mythologies and some dodgy theology. If you can ignore that and just enjoy the adventure, you will like this book. If you read the Twilight series and liked it, you will probably like this as well. Like Twilight, the first book is pretty benign. As the series continues, (Book 3 and beyond) things get darker and more intense. I have read through Book 5 and have found some areas troubling –- particularly the implied casual sexual encounters (both hetero/homosexual), the intensity of the relationship between Clary and Jace (it is a bit over-the-top, like Bella and Edward), and some of the occult practices. Also, like in most YA fiction, the adults seem to be complete idiots –- I don’t know how they did anything before Clary came along. I don’t think this series is for all older teens, but more mature teens that can see through the nonsense might still enjoy the plot.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens
Author website: http://www.cassandraclare.com/
Reviewer: Sabrina Holland
*made into movie 2013*
Core themes: supernatural battle of good vs. evil, intolerance, search for truth, parental/family love and sacrifice
Drugs/alcohol: none in the first book – some wine and tequila drinking in book 5
Religion/occult: some occult occurrences of tarot card usage and reading tea leaves; a cast of villains including different types of demons and “downworlders.” Downworlders are half human/half something else - like a werewolf, vampire, witch etc... The power of the Shadowhunters (ones who hunt demons) is said to have come from the Angel Raziel. Some Shadowhunters choose to believe in God, others do not. There is nothing that glorifies or encourages belief in the occult and its tools. In subsequent books there are more occult practices, including the raising of demons for evil purposes.
Romance/sexuality: 1, 5
Violence/abuse: killing of demons using knives and swords; werewolves battling vampires and zombie types. There is bloodshed, but it is not overly gratuitous or graphic. In later books there are some occult practices, including blood sacrifice and people bitten by vampires, and some more slightly graphic battle scenes.
Vulgarities: 1,3 -- infrequent
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: If you took certain plot points of Harry Potter and crammed it together with Twilight you might get something similar to this series. Overall, this was an okay story if you like supernatural fiction. The trouble I find with this type of fiction is that every author has to explain where the different entities come from and why they are good or bad. This leads to a liberal mixing of ancient mythologies and some dodgy theology. If you can ignore that and just enjoy the adventure, you will like this book. If you read the Twilight series and liked it, you will probably like this as well. Like Twilight, the first book is pretty benign. As the series continues, (Book 3 and beyond) things get darker and more intense. I have read through Book 5 and have found some areas troubling –- particularly the implied casual sexual encounters (both hetero/homosexual), the intensity of the relationship between Clary and Jace (it is a bit over-the-top, like Bella and Edward), and some of the occult practices. Also, like in most YA fiction, the adults seem to be complete idiots –- I don’t know how they did anything before Clary came along. I don’t think this series is for all older teens, but more mature teens that can see through the nonsense might still enjoy the plot.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens
Author website: http://www.cassandraclare.com/
Reviewer: Sabrina Holland
City of Ember, by Jeanne DuPrau (Book of Ember series, book #1)
Please see the review for the series, The Books of Ember
Please see the review for the series, The Books of Ember
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
The Clique, by Lisi Harrison (The Clique series, #1)
Core themes: popularity—trying to become popular, trying to maintain it; cliques and their effect on others; relations between the poor and rich; learning to accept new people
Drugs/alcohol: reference to a man getting drunk
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: 1 Note: Though the book didn't stray out of this category, it was generally trashy.)
Violence/abuse: none
Vulgarities: 1, 2, 3, 4
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: As much as I hate to slam an author's hard work, my honest assessment is that this is a dreadful novel. The plot is one-dimensional, and the writing bumbles along without style. I felt like I was reading the work of a student writer who got extraordinarily lucky in finding a publisher. All the lead characters were annoying, superficial, and unlikeable, until there was some resolution at the end, when they briefly showed a better side. It may be popular with teens, but The Clique (and I assume the rest of the series) is mind candy at its worst.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: http://lisiharrison.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
Core themes: popularity—trying to become popular, trying to maintain it; cliques and their effect on others; relations between the poor and rich; learning to accept new people
Drugs/alcohol: reference to a man getting drunk
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: 1 Note: Though the book didn't stray out of this category, it was generally trashy.)
Violence/abuse: none
Vulgarities: 1, 2, 3, 4
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: As much as I hate to slam an author's hard work, my honest assessment is that this is a dreadful novel. The plot is one-dimensional, and the writing bumbles along without style. I felt like I was reading the work of a student writer who got extraordinarily lucky in finding a publisher. All the lead characters were annoying, superficial, and unlikeable, until there was some resolution at the end, when they briefly showed a better side. It may be popular with teens, but The Clique (and I assume the rest of the series) is mind candy at its worst.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author Website: http://lisiharrison.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Code Name Verity, by Elizabeth Wein
Core themes: power of friendship, sacrifice for one’s country and friends/family.
Drugs/alcohol: cigarette smoking and occasional alcohol consumption – by adults
Religion/occult: Not believing in God, plight of Jewish people during WWII
Romance/sexuality: 1 - Some references to “lecherous behavior” by certain men. Nothing overly descriptive
Violence/abuse: Majority of book takes place at a Nazi headquarters that contains some POW’s. References to different types of interrogation/torture techniques employed by the Nazis. Some battle scenes involving shooting and killing soldiers and prisoners.
Vulgarities: 3, 4
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This is a heart-wrenching tale of two young women who become best friends in England when they both join the war effort. It's a cleverly written, historical novel that keeps you guessing while wrapping you up into intricate details of what life must have been like in occupied France and for those battling against an invading Germany--a tale of heroic deeds, friendship and the ultimate sacrifice. This is probably the best young adult book I have read since I started reviewing YA novels.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: I would consider this book accessible to some younger teens as well, if they are more emotionally mature and have some background in the atrocities and sacrifices that took place during WWII. Would be a good addition to a WWII history curriculum.
Author Website: http://www.elizabethwein.com/
Reviewer: Sabrina Holland
Core themes: power of friendship, sacrifice for one’s country and friends/family.
Drugs/alcohol: cigarette smoking and occasional alcohol consumption – by adults
Religion/occult: Not believing in God, plight of Jewish people during WWII
Romance/sexuality: 1 - Some references to “lecherous behavior” by certain men. Nothing overly descriptive
Violence/abuse: Majority of book takes place at a Nazi headquarters that contains some POW’s. References to different types of interrogation/torture techniques employed by the Nazis. Some battle scenes involving shooting and killing soldiers and prisoners.
Vulgarities: 3, 4
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This is a heart-wrenching tale of two young women who become best friends in England when they both join the war effort. It's a cleverly written, historical novel that keeps you guessing while wrapping you up into intricate details of what life must have been like in occupied France and for those battling against an invading Germany--a tale of heroic deeds, friendship and the ultimate sacrifice. This is probably the best young adult book I have read since I started reviewing YA novels.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: I would consider this book accessible to some younger teens as well, if they are more emotionally mature and have some background in the atrocities and sacrifices that took place during WWII. Would be a good addition to a WWII history curriculum.
Author Website: http://www.elizabethwein.com/
Reviewer: Sabrina Holland
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Confessions of a Murder Suspect, by James Patterson and Maxine Paetro (Confessions series, book 1)
Core themes: justice, pursuit of perfection as measured by academic and worldly success, selfishness, revenge
Drugs/alcohol: a plot involving abuse of prescription medications, one vague memory of teen drinking at a party
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: 4,5 - adultery and a discovery of a homosexual relationship. Both are passed over quickly with no graphic descriptions or much detail given.
Violence/abuse: Plot revolves around solving the deaths of Tandy Angel’s parents. A mildly graphic depiction of when the bodies are discovered. How the children are raised could at times be considered abuse.
Vulgarities: 1
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Relatively fast-paced murder mystery set against the backdrop of New York City and the immensely wealthy and successful Angel family. Tandy Angel and her brothers awaken to the police pounding on their door and the discovery of their dead parents. Tandy takes it upon herself to discover who killed her parent–-even if it means turning in one of her siblings. There is no shortage of suspects, as Malcolm and Maud had many enemies, including their own children. The most troubling thing about this book is not the murder, but how Tandy’s parents decided to raise them. The children are all pushed to extreme levels of academic and physical success, counseled to control all emotions, and punished in ways that would be considered abuse. How Tandy was raised, not the love for her parents, is the catalyst for her decision to finding her parents’ killer. They would expect nothing less than perfection from her, even in crime-solving.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.jamespatterson.com/index.php
Reviewer: Annika Holland
Core themes: justice, pursuit of perfection as measured by academic and worldly success, selfishness, revenge
Drugs/alcohol: a plot involving abuse of prescription medications, one vague memory of teen drinking at a party
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: 4,5 - adultery and a discovery of a homosexual relationship. Both are passed over quickly with no graphic descriptions or much detail given.
Violence/abuse: Plot revolves around solving the deaths of Tandy Angel’s parents. A mildly graphic depiction of when the bodies are discovered. How the children are raised could at times be considered abuse.
Vulgarities: 1
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Relatively fast-paced murder mystery set against the backdrop of New York City and the immensely wealthy and successful Angel family. Tandy Angel and her brothers awaken to the police pounding on their door and the discovery of their dead parents. Tandy takes it upon herself to discover who killed her parent–-even if it means turning in one of her siblings. There is no shortage of suspects, as Malcolm and Maud had many enemies, including their own children. The most troubling thing about this book is not the murder, but how Tandy’s parents decided to raise them. The children are all pushed to extreme levels of academic and physical success, counseled to control all emotions, and punished in ways that would be considered abuse. How Tandy was raised, not the love for her parents, is the catalyst for her decision to finding her parents’ killer. They would expect nothing less than perfection from her, even in crime-solving.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.jamespatterson.com/index.php
Reviewer: Annika Holland
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Conquest, by John Connolly and Jennifer Ridyard (The Chronicles of the Invaders series, book 1)
Core themes: alien invasion; accepting others (even of another species); guerilla war to defend human race; Is a “perfect” life (no global warming, no hunger, no disease) worth relinquishing freedom to be subject to an alien race?; dangers of technology (Internet provided all the information the aliens needed to conquer Earth.); morality of laws (allowing execution of human children); responsibility to consider consequences of actions, even under orders from superior officers; whether androids can be alive, feel emotions, or have rights; medical experimentation; use of mental powers (psychic powers in two of the aliens); reconciling oneself with the taking of life, even in self-defense
Drugs/alcohol: characters drink wine, whiskey, brandy; a cigarette sprinkled with cannabis
Religion/occult: Nairene Sisterhood from the alien planet who are essentially witches (akin to those found in the Dune series); There are lots of interesting questions raised about God and religion given the appearance of a technologically and militarily superior alien race.
Romance/sexuality: 1,2,5
Violence/abuse: An alien race conquers Earth with some violence (like bombing Rome out of existence). There’s quite a lot of graphic violence describing bombings and attacks by guerilla human forces that are rebelling against authority, as well as atrocities committed (mainly by the aliens). There are also Entities that consume humans (and aliens) entirely from the top down on a number of occasions and another alien race that feeds on human blood. At one point, rape is threatened.
Vulgarities: 1, 2, 4, 7
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This book is a more sophisticated science fiction novel for young adults than many recent popular ones. There’s political intrigue, as well as realistic portrayals of the complicated relationships between conquerors and those they conquer. Older teens will appreciate the deeper development.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.johnconnollybooks.com/ (author); http://chroniclesoftheinvaders.com/ (series)
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
Core themes: alien invasion; accepting others (even of another species); guerilla war to defend human race; Is a “perfect” life (no global warming, no hunger, no disease) worth relinquishing freedom to be subject to an alien race?; dangers of technology (Internet provided all the information the aliens needed to conquer Earth.); morality of laws (allowing execution of human children); responsibility to consider consequences of actions, even under orders from superior officers; whether androids can be alive, feel emotions, or have rights; medical experimentation; use of mental powers (psychic powers in two of the aliens); reconciling oneself with the taking of life, even in self-defense
Drugs/alcohol: characters drink wine, whiskey, brandy; a cigarette sprinkled with cannabis
Religion/occult: Nairene Sisterhood from the alien planet who are essentially witches (akin to those found in the Dune series); There are lots of interesting questions raised about God and religion given the appearance of a technologically and militarily superior alien race.
Romance/sexuality: 1,2,5
Violence/abuse: An alien race conquers Earth with some violence (like bombing Rome out of existence). There’s quite a lot of graphic violence describing bombings and attacks by guerilla human forces that are rebelling against authority, as well as atrocities committed (mainly by the aliens). There are also Entities that consume humans (and aliens) entirely from the top down on a number of occasions and another alien race that feeds on human blood. At one point, rape is threatened.
Vulgarities: 1, 2, 4, 7
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This book is a more sophisticated science fiction novel for young adults than many recent popular ones. There’s political intrigue, as well as realistic portrayals of the complicated relationships between conquerors and those they conquer. Older teens will appreciate the deeper development.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.johnconnollybooks.com/ (author); http://chroniclesoftheinvaders.com/ (series)
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Criss Cross, by Lynne Rae Perkins
*2006 Newbery Medal winner*
Core themes: how lives intersect with each other--what is gained, what is missed; the feelings and experiences of adolescents as they develop their sense of identity and go through important changes
Drugs/alcohol: teen character briefly chews tobacco
Religion/occult: character's guitar lessons meet in a church basement and are taught by a pastor; characters briefly discuss sin and confession; a character makes a few comparisons of life to Buddhism and Hinduism
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: none
Vulgarities: 1, 3 (occasional)
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I have to be honest; I did not enjoy this book at all. This is an embarrassing confession to make, because I am an English teacher and feel like I should be on board with all medal winners. I should get what the author intended and understand the brilliance within it. I should understand what caused the medal committee to bestow upon it the coveted award that magically makes its recipients immortal. Usually I can; this time I can't. It had a loose storyline with very little of anything happening in the entire book (which was by design, I learned later). Frankly, I thought it was--dare I say it?--well, boring.
When I finished it, I immediately went onto the internet to try to understand why it deserved the Newbery medal, because I have been proven wrong in my assessments of art before. So please, take my review with a grain of salt, and do a little background study of Criss Cross before you make a decision about suggesting it to your teen. I think this is one teen novel that takes some pre-reading background study and some post-reading analysis in order to fully appreciate it. My internet research hasn't changed my opinion about the book, but it has left me open to taking deeper look at it sometime, which I believe most art deserves.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens /all teens/ no teens. (Caveat--I recommend this book only if the pre-reading and post-reading activities I suggested are added in)
Author Website: http://lynnerae.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*2006 Newbery Medal winner*
Core themes: how lives intersect with each other--what is gained, what is missed; the feelings and experiences of adolescents as they develop their sense of identity and go through important changes
Drugs/alcohol: teen character briefly chews tobacco
Religion/occult: character's guitar lessons meet in a church basement and are taught by a pastor; characters briefly discuss sin and confession; a character makes a few comparisons of life to Buddhism and Hinduism
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: none
Vulgarities: 1, 3 (occasional)
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I have to be honest; I did not enjoy this book at all. This is an embarrassing confession to make, because I am an English teacher and feel like I should be on board with all medal winners. I should get what the author intended and understand the brilliance within it. I should understand what caused the medal committee to bestow upon it the coveted award that magically makes its recipients immortal. Usually I can; this time I can't. It had a loose storyline with very little of anything happening in the entire book (which was by design, I learned later). Frankly, I thought it was--dare I say it?--well, boring.
When I finished it, I immediately went onto the internet to try to understand why it deserved the Newbery medal, because I have been proven wrong in my assessments of art before. So please, take my review with a grain of salt, and do a little background study of Criss Cross before you make a decision about suggesting it to your teen. I think this is one teen novel that takes some pre-reading background study and some post-reading analysis in order to fully appreciate it. My internet research hasn't changed my opinion about the book, but it has left me open to taking deeper look at it sometime, which I believe most art deserves.
I would suggest this book to younger teens / older teens /all teens/ no teens. (Caveat--I recommend this book only if the pre-reading and post-reading activities I suggested are added in)
Author Website: http://lynnerae.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Crossed, by Allie Condie (Matched Trilogy series, book 2)
Core themes: love, death
Drugs/alcohol: pills supposedly used to keep a person alive
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: mentions of death/murder
Vulgarities: 1
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Just like the first book in this series, Matched, I could not put it down. New characters are introduced, which makes the book more exciting. This book is nearly as clean as the book before it with the exception of a couple (and by couple I literally mean two) curse words. I suggest continuing the Matched series if you’ve read the first book.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://allycondie.com/
Reviewer: Annika Blomquist
Core themes: love, death
Drugs/alcohol: pills supposedly used to keep a person alive
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: mentions of death/murder
Vulgarities: 1
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: Just like the first book in this series, Matched, I could not put it down. New characters are introduced, which makes the book more exciting. This book is nearly as clean as the book before it with the exception of a couple (and by couple I literally mean two) curse words. I suggest continuing the Matched series if you’ve read the first book.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://allycondie.com/
Reviewer: Annika Blomquist
