The "E" Reviews--See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Echo, by Pam Munoz Ryan
*2016 Newbery Honor Book; NYT Bestseller; The Kirkus Prize ; New York Times Editors’ Choice; ALA Notable Book; New York Historical Society Book Prize; National Parenting Publications Gold Award; Publishers Weekly Best Books of the Year; Washington Post Best Books of the Year; NPR 2015 Great Reads; New York Public Library 100 Titles for Reading and Sharing; New York Times Notable Book; SCIBA Middle Grade Book of the Year; The Audie Award; International Literacy Association Notable Book for a Global Society; Booksource Scout Award; NCTE Notable Book in the Language Arts; ILA/CBC Children’s Choice; The Américas Award*
Why this book is worth considering:
I began reading this beautiful novel with indifference and doubt and only for professional reasons--not for this website. It is a middle-grade novel, which I don't typically review. As I read it, though, I began to feel that it transcended age level, that it is one of those novels that belongs to everyone old enough to read it. On one level, yes, it is for middle-grade children, because the characters are under 13 for much of the story. On another, though, it has a depth and complexity that will appeal to teens and adults, too. This is the second novel I have reviewed by Ryan, and it is even more moving and beautiful than the first (Esperanza Rising). In fact, it brought me to tears a half-dozen times before I finished--in a good way. No matter your age, I dare you to read it and regret it!
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
I can't think of one bad thing to say about this novel. Nope, not a thing. If you've read many of my other reviews, you'll realize how rare this is.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.pammunozryan.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*2016 Newbery Honor Book; NYT Bestseller; The Kirkus Prize ; New York Times Editors’ Choice; ALA Notable Book; New York Historical Society Book Prize; National Parenting Publications Gold Award; Publishers Weekly Best Books of the Year; Washington Post Best Books of the Year; NPR 2015 Great Reads; New York Public Library 100 Titles for Reading and Sharing; New York Times Notable Book; SCIBA Middle Grade Book of the Year; The Audie Award; International Literacy Association Notable Book for a Global Society; Booksource Scout Award; NCTE Notable Book in the Language Arts; ILA/CBC Children’s Choice; The Américas Award*
Why this book is worth considering:
I began reading this beautiful novel with indifference and doubt and only for professional reasons--not for this website. It is a middle-grade novel, which I don't typically review. As I read it, though, I began to feel that it transcended age level, that it is one of those novels that belongs to everyone old enough to read it. On one level, yes, it is for middle-grade children, because the characters are under 13 for much of the story. On another, though, it has a depth and complexity that will appeal to teens and adults, too. This is the second novel I have reviewed by Ryan, and it is even more moving and beautiful than the first (Esperanza Rising). In fact, it brought me to tears a half-dozen times before I finished--in a good way. No matter your age, I dare you to read it and regret it!
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
I can't think of one bad thing to say about this novel. Nope, not a thing. If you've read many of my other reviews, you'll realize how rare this is.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.pammunozryan.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
The Edge of Falling, by Rebecca Serle
Why this book is worth considering:
The main value of this novel is it's exploration of grief after the loss of a loved one. Serle traces with sensitivity the the path of grief her protagonist walks after her little sister drowns. Teens experiencing grief of their own may find comfort in this novel, although religious readers may be disappointed that there is nothing in the novel to help them grapple with the spiritual struggles and doubts they may experience.
Other than this, the most enjoyable part of novel for me was the ending (pretty exciting and stronger writing than the rest of the novel, actually) and the setting, the wealthy community of New York City. Prep schools, luxury restaurants and shopping, fancy (and second!) homes are protagonist McAlister's world. Although the themes of the novel are serious, teens living in more ordinary circumstances may enjoy this peek into this elite lifestyle. And to be as fair as possible, one blurb said that if Pretty Little Liars and Gossip Girls had a baby, this would be it, but I heartily disagree. Having read both of those smutty novels, I can promise that this one has much more substance and is much cleaner than either one of them.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
The important and well-treated theme of grief and loss aside, my main reaction to this novel is "Ho-hum, another one." Maybe I've just read too many YA books by now, but I read the novel feeling like I've seen all the same characters before. Nice, fairly intelligent but humble protagonist--check. Handsome, sweet, perfect boyfriend (or ex-boyfriend)--check. Irresistible bad boy with a dark past--check. Wild but wonderful best friend (and requisite conflict with that friend)--check. Neglectful and/or distant parents--check. Backstory fed to the reader only little by little--check. There just isn't much fresh material here. I don't know, maybe I'm missing something. A jacket blurb says, "I swooned. I cried, I loved, loved, loved this delicious novel." Is this novel just not my thing? I don't know, but I can't relate to that at all. To me, this was more of a "been-there-done-that" read. It will probably appeal to most teen girls, unless they, like me, have been around the block with YA novels a few too many times.
Regarding specific content of concern, this novel is cleaner than many YA novels in terms of drinking and drugs (some drinking, no recreational drugs), swearing (some, including very occasional "f***" and blasphemy), and sex (protagonist is unashamedly but infrequently sexually active, but the one sexual situation isn't graphic). Religion and the occult have little place in the novel. I think I recall only one part where a character talks about trying to reach his mom's spirit through a psychic as part of trying to process his grief after her death.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: Though there are far worse YA novels than this one as far as concerning content goes, it's low literary quality would compel me to recommend it mostly to those teens dealing with grief and loss. They may find genuine solace and support in this novel.
Author website: http://rebeccaserle.com/author.html
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
Why this book is worth considering:
The main value of this novel is it's exploration of grief after the loss of a loved one. Serle traces with sensitivity the the path of grief her protagonist walks after her little sister drowns. Teens experiencing grief of their own may find comfort in this novel, although religious readers may be disappointed that there is nothing in the novel to help them grapple with the spiritual struggles and doubts they may experience.
Other than this, the most enjoyable part of novel for me was the ending (pretty exciting and stronger writing than the rest of the novel, actually) and the setting, the wealthy community of New York City. Prep schools, luxury restaurants and shopping, fancy (and second!) homes are protagonist McAlister's world. Although the themes of the novel are serious, teens living in more ordinary circumstances may enjoy this peek into this elite lifestyle. And to be as fair as possible, one blurb said that if Pretty Little Liars and Gossip Girls had a baby, this would be it, but I heartily disagree. Having read both of those smutty novels, I can promise that this one has much more substance and is much cleaner than either one of them.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
The important and well-treated theme of grief and loss aside, my main reaction to this novel is "Ho-hum, another one." Maybe I've just read too many YA books by now, but I read the novel feeling like I've seen all the same characters before. Nice, fairly intelligent but humble protagonist--check. Handsome, sweet, perfect boyfriend (or ex-boyfriend)--check. Irresistible bad boy with a dark past--check. Wild but wonderful best friend (and requisite conflict with that friend)--check. Neglectful and/or distant parents--check. Backstory fed to the reader only little by little--check. There just isn't much fresh material here. I don't know, maybe I'm missing something. A jacket blurb says, "I swooned. I cried, I loved, loved, loved this delicious novel." Is this novel just not my thing? I don't know, but I can't relate to that at all. To me, this was more of a "been-there-done-that" read. It will probably appeal to most teen girls, unless they, like me, have been around the block with YA novels a few too many times.
Regarding specific content of concern, this novel is cleaner than many YA novels in terms of drinking and drugs (some drinking, no recreational drugs), swearing (some, including very occasional "f***" and blasphemy), and sex (protagonist is unashamedly but infrequently sexually active, but the one sexual situation isn't graphic). Religion and the occult have little place in the novel. I think I recall only one part where a character talks about trying to reach his mom's spirit through a psychic as part of trying to process his grief after her death.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: Though there are far worse YA novels than this one as far as concerning content goes, it's low literary quality would compel me to recommend it mostly to those teens dealing with grief and loss. They may find genuine solace and support in this novel.
Author website: http://rebeccaserle.com/author.html
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
Eleanor's Story: An American Girl in Hitler's Germany, by Eleanor Ramrath Garner
*International Reading Association Award, 2000*
Core themes: World War II, survival, family loyalty, finding strength in the midst of tragedy and horror; American patriotism
Drugs/alcohol: some drinking by soldiers
Religion/occult: account of Eleanor and brother being catechized and given first communion in Catholic church; many references to Eleanor's struggle to maintain faith in the face of war horrors--however, family is not particularly religious but more cultural Catholics; many references to Eleanor's dependence on and trust in her guardian angels (whom she calls the "Invisibles"), in which she has more faith than any Person of the triune God; a number of references to her print of Boticelli's painting of the Virgin Mary, to which she often turns for comfort
Romance/sexuality: 1, 2 Note: The #2 designation partly involves a man exposing himself to Eleanor and friend and another man caught skinny-dipping by Eleanor and friends who is forced to come out of the water in their full view.
Violence/abuse: Much detailed, horrific violence--mostly relevant to the war itself. Accounts of bombings, civilian deaths (including children and teens), rapes, and other tragedies. Eleanor and her brother also experience mild verbal and physical abuse by their parents as a normal part of their upbringing, including slapping and hitting. This is tempered by many references to love and family loyalty, but the abuse may be disturbing to some readers.
Vulgarities: 1
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: During the first half of this memoir, I found myself unable to ignore the mediocre writing. At times it seemed as if the author was just slapping down any and all memories that occurred to her in a snapshot fashion and with an artless use of language. If the book had continued in this manner, I would have given it only two stars. As the account of the war began to intensify, however, Eleanor began to warm to her story. Suddenly, the narrative became infused with the strong, seamless story arc that the first half lacked, and her writing gained power, passion, and the kind of detail that was needed to bring to life the full horror and agonies of the war. Thus, for the second half of the book, I have to give it four stars.
Writing artistry aside, this is one of the most important books about World War II that I have ever read, which is definitely not something I expected from a Scholastic book. I expected a tame and gentle introduction to the realities of WWII, something to give young readers a narrow view of it to enable them to begin to understand what it was all about. In reality, though, Eleanor's story was profound and unforgettable. It also gave me an entirely new perspective on the war--not only because she was an American trapped in Germany for the entire war, but also because it was the first account of the war I've ever read that helped me understand what it was like for the people who had no direct association with the sufferings of Jews and other victims of Hitler's concentration camps. This is a story of the ordinary German citizens who were caught in the crossfire of the invasions and devastation of their country, especially the citizens of Berlin, which was utterly destroyed. I have always thought that the German citizens lived comfortable, ordinary lives throughout the war, at least relative to the victims of the Holocaust. In reality, though, their world was also hellish, just in different ways from the Holocaust victims. Many of them suffered horribly and died of starvation, sickness, bombings, or cold. Others went through all kinds of other awful things that are difficult for us to imagine today, such as walking hundreds of miles to find family members.
It is important to understand that Eleanor's story does not in any way seek to undermine or lessen the tragedy of the millions who suffered as Holocaust victims. Indeed, most Germans did not understand what was really happening to the Jews and other minorities until after the war was over. Hers is simply another perspective. It is a story of survival and family loyalty, an important piece of war history for anyone interested in this devastating chapter of the 20th century.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: The violence depicted in this book is graphic at times. It may be disturbing to sensitive readers.
Author's website: none
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*International Reading Association Award, 2000*
Core themes: World War II, survival, family loyalty, finding strength in the midst of tragedy and horror; American patriotism
Drugs/alcohol: some drinking by soldiers
Religion/occult: account of Eleanor and brother being catechized and given first communion in Catholic church; many references to Eleanor's struggle to maintain faith in the face of war horrors--however, family is not particularly religious but more cultural Catholics; many references to Eleanor's dependence on and trust in her guardian angels (whom she calls the "Invisibles"), in which she has more faith than any Person of the triune God; a number of references to her print of Boticelli's painting of the Virgin Mary, to which she often turns for comfort
Romance/sexuality: 1, 2 Note: The #2 designation partly involves a man exposing himself to Eleanor and friend and another man caught skinny-dipping by Eleanor and friends who is forced to come out of the water in their full view.
Violence/abuse: Much detailed, horrific violence--mostly relevant to the war itself. Accounts of bombings, civilian deaths (including children and teens), rapes, and other tragedies. Eleanor and her brother also experience mild verbal and physical abuse by their parents as a normal part of their upbringing, including slapping and hitting. This is tempered by many references to love and family loyalty, but the abuse may be disturbing to some readers.
Vulgarities: 1
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: During the first half of this memoir, I found myself unable to ignore the mediocre writing. At times it seemed as if the author was just slapping down any and all memories that occurred to her in a snapshot fashion and with an artless use of language. If the book had continued in this manner, I would have given it only two stars. As the account of the war began to intensify, however, Eleanor began to warm to her story. Suddenly, the narrative became infused with the strong, seamless story arc that the first half lacked, and her writing gained power, passion, and the kind of detail that was needed to bring to life the full horror and agonies of the war. Thus, for the second half of the book, I have to give it four stars.
Writing artistry aside, this is one of the most important books about World War II that I have ever read, which is definitely not something I expected from a Scholastic book. I expected a tame and gentle introduction to the realities of WWII, something to give young readers a narrow view of it to enable them to begin to understand what it was all about. In reality, though, Eleanor's story was profound and unforgettable. It also gave me an entirely new perspective on the war--not only because she was an American trapped in Germany for the entire war, but also because it was the first account of the war I've ever read that helped me understand what it was like for the people who had no direct association with the sufferings of Jews and other victims of Hitler's concentration camps. This is a story of the ordinary German citizens who were caught in the crossfire of the invasions and devastation of their country, especially the citizens of Berlin, which was utterly destroyed. I have always thought that the German citizens lived comfortable, ordinary lives throughout the war, at least relative to the victims of the Holocaust. In reality, though, their world was also hellish, just in different ways from the Holocaust victims. Many of them suffered horribly and died of starvation, sickness, bombings, or cold. Others went through all kinds of other awful things that are difficult for us to imagine today, such as walking hundreds of miles to find family members.
It is important to understand that Eleanor's story does not in any way seek to undermine or lessen the tragedy of the millions who suffered as Holocaust victims. Indeed, most Germans did not understand what was really happening to the Jews and other minorities until after the war was over. Hers is simply another perspective. It is a story of survival and family loyalty, an important piece of war history for anyone interested in this devastating chapter of the 20th century.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: The violence depicted in this book is graphic at times. It may be disturbing to sensitive readers.
Author's website: none
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
The Elite, by Kiera Cass (The Selection series, book 2)
See The Selection for full review.
Why this book is worth considering:
Like book 1, this second volume in The Selection series is a fun and page-turning leisure read for teen girls. It remains sex-free with very little swearing (a couple of "d--" and one "G--"), and the plot twists and turns. I will definitely read book 3!
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
This sequel takes a little darker turn than book 1 with more violence, as danger becomes more than a rumored specter, setting everyone on edge. Rebels attack the palace several times with a number of non-graphic fatalities. More vividly, however, the story features a scene in which a public caning/whipping takes place. This is one of the most riveting, powerful scenes I have read in YA literature, made all the more disturbing because it contrasts so starkly against the glitter and fun of the selection thus far. Though no one dies and the scene is actually softened by a somewhat happy outcome later in the book, sensitive readers may find this scene unpleasantly haunting. Otherwise, the story continues to be fascinating and fun. Wary parents may not like that one of the characters shows some lustful/inappropriate behavior toward the prince, but again, there is no sex. My only complaint is that the author overused the device of having the protagonist flip-flop in her feelings between the prince and her first love, which eventually seemed like a contrived way to extend the story more than anything else. I would have liked to see other complications develop more instead, such as maybe more venturing beyond the palace into society.
Literary artistry: * * * * * Note: The writing seemed a little weaker in this novel.
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See The Selection for full review.
Why this book is worth considering:
Like book 1, this second volume in The Selection series is a fun and page-turning leisure read for teen girls. It remains sex-free with very little swearing (a couple of "d--" and one "G--"), and the plot twists and turns. I will definitely read book 3!
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
This sequel takes a little darker turn than book 1 with more violence, as danger becomes more than a rumored specter, setting everyone on edge. Rebels attack the palace several times with a number of non-graphic fatalities. More vividly, however, the story features a scene in which a public caning/whipping takes place. This is one of the most riveting, powerful scenes I have read in YA literature, made all the more disturbing because it contrasts so starkly against the glitter and fun of the selection thus far. Though no one dies and the scene is actually softened by a somewhat happy outcome later in the book, sensitive readers may find this scene unpleasantly haunting. Otherwise, the story continues to be fascinating and fun. Wary parents may not like that one of the characters shows some lustful/inappropriate behavior toward the prince, but again, there is no sex. My only complaint is that the author overused the device of having the protagonist flip-flop in her feelings between the prince and her first love, which eventually seemed like a contrived way to extend the story more than anything else. I would have liked to see other complications develop more instead, such as maybe more venturing beyond the palace into society.
Literary artistry: * * * * * Note: The writing seemed a little weaker in this novel.
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Emerald Green, by Kerstin Gier (The Ruby Red Trilogy series, book 3)
Please see the review for The Ruby Red Trilogy.
Please see the review for The Ruby Red Trilogy.
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Emily’s Dress and Other Missing Things, by Kathryn Burak
*Edgar Award (Mystery Writer of America) Nominee–Best Young Adult Mystery 2013; Independent Booksellers Best New Voices 2012; ABC Best Books for Children 2012; MAINE Cream of the Crop 2013; Bank Street Best Children’s Books of the Year; Tri-State Reviews Committee Books of Note – Master List; Booklist--starred review*
Core themes: healing after trauma, friendship, guilt
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: historical reference to Emily Dickinson’s father making her attend a tent revivalist meeting to declare her faith
Romance/sexuality: none except a reference to a friend who decides he is gay
Violence/abuse: reference to suicide attempts, two instances of someone getting punched in the face
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I picked this book up on a whim and was pleasantly surprised by the excellent writing and intriguing plotline. The story revolves around Claire, a high school senior for the second year, and how she copes with the death of her mother and her missing best friend. The writer deftly intertwines Claire’s emotional journey/recovery with two mysteries – one involving her best friend and the other concerning Emily Dickinson’s dress. She finds help along the way in unexpected places and learns to trust in someone other than herself. Through her thoughts we see the clever, funny side of Claire, and in her actions we see the torment she lives with daily. At times it is hard to read how slowly and physically Claire reacts to things, but these actions are both poignant and purposeful, so that the reader can understand her true struggle.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.kathrynburak.com/
Reviewer: Sabrina Holland
*Edgar Award (Mystery Writer of America) Nominee–Best Young Adult Mystery 2013; Independent Booksellers Best New Voices 2012; ABC Best Books for Children 2012; MAINE Cream of the Crop 2013; Bank Street Best Children’s Books of the Year; Tri-State Reviews Committee Books of Note – Master List; Booklist--starred review*
Core themes: healing after trauma, friendship, guilt
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: historical reference to Emily Dickinson’s father making her attend a tent revivalist meeting to declare her faith
Romance/sexuality: none except a reference to a friend who decides he is gay
Violence/abuse: reference to suicide attempts, two instances of someone getting punched in the face
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I picked this book up on a whim and was pleasantly surprised by the excellent writing and intriguing plotline. The story revolves around Claire, a high school senior for the second year, and how she copes with the death of her mother and her missing best friend. The writer deftly intertwines Claire’s emotional journey/recovery with two mysteries – one involving her best friend and the other concerning Emily Dickinson’s dress. She finds help along the way in unexpected places and learns to trust in someone other than herself. Through her thoughts we see the clever, funny side of Claire, and in her actions we see the torment she lives with daily. At times it is hard to read how slowly and physically Claire reacts to things, but these actions are both poignant and purposeful, so that the reader can understand her true struggle.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.kathrynburak.com/
Reviewer: Sabrina Holland
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Enchanted, by Alethea Kontis (The Woodcutter Sisters series, book 1)
*Kirkus Best Teen Book of 2012*
Core Themes: It is a fantasy set in a magical kingdom, so it includes magic - good and bad - , love, and family
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: there are witches and magic but as a support for the story instead of witchcraft.
Romance/sexuality: very innocent romance; a slow-burn, true love story, no sexual scenes or anything PG-13. I would probably rate it as a G book when considering the romance.
Violence/abuse: the king tries to murder his wife; he uses magic, so not very gory
Vulgarities: not that I remember, I don't think there were any
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I really liked this book. It was the same "true love turned the frog into a prince with a kiss" story but it steered away from the cliche and gave the story it's own dark twist. At the same time, it's sweet, it's lighthearted, it deals with true love and a magical, wild family. It's a beautiful story and quite fun to read. It's not heavy reading, just something to cure boredom, but quite enjoyable.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://aletheakontis.com/
Reviewer: Merry Blomquist
*Kirkus Best Teen Book of 2012*
Core Themes: It is a fantasy set in a magical kingdom, so it includes magic - good and bad - , love, and family
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: there are witches and magic but as a support for the story instead of witchcraft.
Romance/sexuality: very innocent romance; a slow-burn, true love story, no sexual scenes or anything PG-13. I would probably rate it as a G book when considering the romance.
Violence/abuse: the king tries to murder his wife; he uses magic, so not very gory
Vulgarities: not that I remember, I don't think there were any
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I really liked this book. It was the same "true love turned the frog into a prince with a kiss" story but it steered away from the cliche and gave the story it's own dark twist. At the same time, it's sweet, it's lighthearted, it deals with true love and a magical, wild family. It's a beautiful story and quite fun to read. It's not heavy reading, just something to cure boredom, but quite enjoyable.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://aletheakontis.com/
Reviewer: Merry Blomquist
Esperanza Rising, by Pam Munoz Ryan
*Pura Belpé Medal; Jane Addams Children’s Book Award; The Willa Cather Award; Américas Award Honor Book; ALA Top Ten Best Books for Young Adults; Publisher’s Weekly Best Book of the Year; NY Public Library 100 Titles for Reading and Sharing; IRA Notable Book for a Global Society; NCSS Notable Book for Young People; Jefferson Cup Award Worthy of Note; Los Angeles Times Book Prize Finalist; Smithsonian Best Book of the Year; Southern California Judy Lopez Memorial Award; Arizona Young Adult Book Award*
Why this book is worth considering:
Usually, I don't review middle-grade books like this one, but sometimes I discover one that may appeal to younger adolescents. Esperanza Rising is one of these. Not only that, it is a beautiful story (well-deserving of its many awards), rich in the kind of historical context and emotional depth that stays with the reader long after the last page. It can be a difficult story at times, because most of the novel is centered on the destructive aftermath of Esperanza's father's death on their ranch in Mexico. But in Spanish "Esperanza" means "hope," and that is a central theme in what is ultimately an uplifting, inspiring story. For those interested in multicultural, coming-of-age, and complex stories (rather than mind candy), this is an especially excellent choice.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
Personally, I would not hesitate to hand this book to my children, but it does contain a little content that may be problematic for some families. Early in the novel Esperanza's father and ranch hands are murdered by bandits, and her uncles are wicked and self-seeking men who destroy the lives of all who live on the ranch. The story also confronts difficult issues head-on, such as the "voluntary deportation" disaster of the Great Depression and the prejudice Mexican immigrants faced at that time. The author also does not shy away from the Catholic religious beliefs and traditions of Esperanza and her mother. She does not proselytize by any means, but she does include mention of their practices when realistic in the context of the story. The novel does not contain vulgar language, drugs/alcohol, or more than the merest hint of romance.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.pammunozryan.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*Pura Belpé Medal; Jane Addams Children’s Book Award; The Willa Cather Award; Américas Award Honor Book; ALA Top Ten Best Books for Young Adults; Publisher’s Weekly Best Book of the Year; NY Public Library 100 Titles for Reading and Sharing; IRA Notable Book for a Global Society; NCSS Notable Book for Young People; Jefferson Cup Award Worthy of Note; Los Angeles Times Book Prize Finalist; Smithsonian Best Book of the Year; Southern California Judy Lopez Memorial Award; Arizona Young Adult Book Award*
Why this book is worth considering:
Usually, I don't review middle-grade books like this one, but sometimes I discover one that may appeal to younger adolescents. Esperanza Rising is one of these. Not only that, it is a beautiful story (well-deserving of its many awards), rich in the kind of historical context and emotional depth that stays with the reader long after the last page. It can be a difficult story at times, because most of the novel is centered on the destructive aftermath of Esperanza's father's death on their ranch in Mexico. But in Spanish "Esperanza" means "hope," and that is a central theme in what is ultimately an uplifting, inspiring story. For those interested in multicultural, coming-of-age, and complex stories (rather than mind candy), this is an especially excellent choice.
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
Personally, I would not hesitate to hand this book to my children, but it does contain a little content that may be problematic for some families. Early in the novel Esperanza's father and ranch hands are murdered by bandits, and her uncles are wicked and self-seeking men who destroy the lives of all who live on the ranch. The story also confronts difficult issues head-on, such as the "voluntary deportation" disaster of the Great Depression and the prejudice Mexican immigrants faced at that time. The author also does not shy away from the Catholic religious beliefs and traditions of Esperanza and her mother. She does not proselytize by any means, but she does include mention of their practices when realistic in the context of the story. The novel does not contain vulgar language, drugs/alcohol, or more than the merest hint of romance.
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.pammunozryan.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
The Ever-after Bird, by Ann Rinaldi
Core themes: the abolitionist movement in helping slaves escape the South; the Underground Railroad; the feelings of some white Southern people toward people of color
Drugs/alcohol: social drinkingReligion/occult: "voodoo" meetings
Romance/sexuality: 1, 4
Violence/abuse: significant mistreatment of slaves; cruel punishment of slaves (whipping, hanging, etc.)
Vulgarities: 1, 2, 3, 6
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This story presents a picture of slavery in the pre-Civil War United States southern states. It is told through the eyes of a northern teenage white girl who visits the South during this time. Judging from other resources concerning slavery, I believe this book to be accurate in its presentation of the treatment of slaves by some Southern white owners. Since this story is fiction, any older teen who is interested in researching this era of United States history would find this book a useful addition to his reading, because it presents the slavery problem in a story-form, rather than simply stating the facts, such as a non-fiction resource would. It must be understood, however, that this story presents slavery and the pre-Civil War plantation system from the Northern American's viewpoint. It includes little of the Southern plantation owner's true views and feelings of that society or the feelings of a teenage white child of a Southern slave owner, except what the visitors from the North see and hear. This is one reason I recommend this book for older teens, since they may be more discerning of this angle.
I would suggest this book to younger teens/older teens/ all teens/ no teens.
Author website: http://www.annrinaldi.net/
Reviewer: Joy Pardue
Core themes: the abolitionist movement in helping slaves escape the South; the Underground Railroad; the feelings of some white Southern people toward people of color
Drugs/alcohol: social drinkingReligion/occult: "voodoo" meetings
Romance/sexuality: 1, 4
Violence/abuse: significant mistreatment of slaves; cruel punishment of slaves (whipping, hanging, etc.)
Vulgarities: 1, 2, 3, 6
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This story presents a picture of slavery in the pre-Civil War United States southern states. It is told through the eyes of a northern teenage white girl who visits the South during this time. Judging from other resources concerning slavery, I believe this book to be accurate in its presentation of the treatment of slaves by some Southern white owners. Since this story is fiction, any older teen who is interested in researching this era of United States history would find this book a useful addition to his reading, because it presents the slavery problem in a story-form, rather than simply stating the facts, such as a non-fiction resource would. It must be understood, however, that this story presents slavery and the pre-Civil War plantation system from the Northern American's viewpoint. It includes little of the Southern plantation owner's true views and feelings of that society or the feelings of a teenage white child of a Southern slave owner, except what the visitors from the North see and hear. This is one reason I recommend this book for older teens, since they may be more discerning of this angle.
I would suggest this book to younger teens/older teens/ all teens/ no teens.
Author website: http://www.annrinaldi.net/
Reviewer: Joy Pardue
Every Falling Star: The True Story of How I Survived and Escaped North Korea, by Sungju Lee and Susan McClelland
*An Indies Introduce Selection of the American Booksellers Association; A Junior Library Guild Selection, 2016; Parent’s Choice Award winner, 2016; film optioned by Patrick Aiello of Big Wheel Entertainment*
Why this book is worth considering:
A true story that reads like a first-person novel, this is a moving and powerful memoir about an abandoned teenage boy trying to survive by his wits in one of the most restricted countries on earth--North Korea. Parents will appreciate that not only is their teen reading a fascinating story, they are also getting a slice of history that they won't find in their history books. Even better, author Sungju Lee is an inspiring example of how the human spirit can survive and even triumph over unbelievable adversity, since today he lives in America with a master's degree and a career helping other North Korean refugges. Boys and girls alike will enjoy his amazing story!
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
Honestly, I can think of only one reason you might bypass this book. It does contain some disturbing violence--a fairly graphic execution that Lee was forced to watch as a child, street fighting, a couple of tragic deaths, and physical beatings by soldiers. He also gently mentions the rape of young girls in the prison he suffered for awhile, as well as how he helped bring customers to prostitutes in order to make some money to buy food. Occasionally, he also mentions some of the pagan folk gods/spirits that he and his mother petitioned for help when life became desperate. Other than that, this memoir is one most parents would be glad to hand their teens!
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.smcclelland.com/every-falling-star/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*An Indies Introduce Selection of the American Booksellers Association; A Junior Library Guild Selection, 2016; Parent’s Choice Award winner, 2016; film optioned by Patrick Aiello of Big Wheel Entertainment*
Why this book is worth considering:
A true story that reads like a first-person novel, this is a moving and powerful memoir about an abandoned teenage boy trying to survive by his wits in one of the most restricted countries on earth--North Korea. Parents will appreciate that not only is their teen reading a fascinating story, they are also getting a slice of history that they won't find in their history books. Even better, author Sungju Lee is an inspiring example of how the human spirit can survive and even triumph over unbelievable adversity, since today he lives in America with a master's degree and a career helping other North Korean refugges. Boys and girls alike will enjoy his amazing story!
Why this book may not be right for your teen:
Honestly, I can think of only one reason you might bypass this book. It does contain some disturbing violence--a fairly graphic execution that Lee was forced to watch as a child, street fighting, a couple of tragic deaths, and physical beatings by soldiers. He also gently mentions the rape of young girls in the prison he suffered for awhile, as well as how he helped bring customers to prostitutes in order to make some money to buy food. Occasionally, he also mentions some of the pagan folk gods/spirits that he and his mother petitioned for help when life became desperate. Other than that, this memoir is one most parents would be glad to hand their teens!
Literary artistry: * * * * *
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website: http://www.smcclelland.com/every-falling-star/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
Every Soul a Star, by Wendy Mass
*1st annual Homeschool Book Award; Rebecca Caudill Young Readers’ Book Award, Illinois, 2012; South Carolina Children’s Book Award, 2011; Oklahoma Sequoyah Book Award, 2010-2011; Iowa Children’s Choice Award, 2010-2011; Maud Hart Lovelace Award, Minnesota, 2010-2011; Black-Eyed Susan Book Award, Maryland, 2011; Colorado Blue Spruce Young Adult Book Award, 2011; William Allen White Award, Kansas, 2011; Kentucky Bluegrass Award, 2010; New Hampshire Great Stone Face Book Award 2009-10; Chosen as a CCBC (Cooperative Children’s Book Center) Choice Selection*
Core themes: the value of pushing yourself to become all you were meant to be; learning what's important and realizing our place in the scheme of things; the wonder and beauty of astronomy and our universe; coping with big and sudden changes; learning to care about people different from ourselves; beauty is in the eye of the beholder; rising to challenges; the human quest for immortality
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: Egyptian woman praying during eclipse--explains to main character why her Muslim faith charges her not to watch the eclipse; novel is subtly atheistic as a whole, presenting the idea that we are immortal even without God, because our atoms travel to the other side of the universe to become parts of other things
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: none
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I thought this novel was so well-written and enjoyable that I gave it to my daughter as soon as I finished, who was resistant at first but ended up enjoying it as much as I did. The atheistic content did bother me a little, but because it was a minor part of the story, I felt it did not cancel out the story's many virtues. The main characters were interesting, authentic, and well-drawn, and although there was one part that felt too contrived, the entire premise turned out to be more fascinating than the jacket blurb led me to believe. Plus, I learned some new things about astronomy! You don't have to be interested in science to enjoy this novel, by the way. Astronomy is the hinge on which the story turns, but the heart of the novel is firmly in its characters.
I would suggest this book to younger teens/older teens/ all teens/ no teens.
Author website: http://wendymass.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
*1st annual Homeschool Book Award; Rebecca Caudill Young Readers’ Book Award, Illinois, 2012; South Carolina Children’s Book Award, 2011; Oklahoma Sequoyah Book Award, 2010-2011; Iowa Children’s Choice Award, 2010-2011; Maud Hart Lovelace Award, Minnesota, 2010-2011; Black-Eyed Susan Book Award, Maryland, 2011; Colorado Blue Spruce Young Adult Book Award, 2011; William Allen White Award, Kansas, 2011; Kentucky Bluegrass Award, 2010; New Hampshire Great Stone Face Book Award 2009-10; Chosen as a CCBC (Cooperative Children’s Book Center) Choice Selection*
Core themes: the value of pushing yourself to become all you were meant to be; learning what's important and realizing our place in the scheme of things; the wonder and beauty of astronomy and our universe; coping with big and sudden changes; learning to care about people different from ourselves; beauty is in the eye of the beholder; rising to challenges; the human quest for immortality
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: Egyptian woman praying during eclipse--explains to main character why her Muslim faith charges her not to watch the eclipse; novel is subtly atheistic as a whole, presenting the idea that we are immortal even without God, because our atoms travel to the other side of the universe to become parts of other things
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: none
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: I thought this novel was so well-written and enjoyable that I gave it to my daughter as soon as I finished, who was resistant at first but ended up enjoying it as much as I did. The atheistic content did bother me a little, but because it was a minor part of the story, I felt it did not cancel out the story's many virtues. The main characters were interesting, authentic, and well-drawn, and although there was one part that felt too contrived, the entire premise turned out to be more fascinating than the jacket blurb led me to believe. Plus, I learned some new things about astronomy! You don't have to be interested in science to enjoy this novel, by the way. Astronomy is the hinge on which the story turns, but the heart of the novel is firmly in its characters.
I would suggest this book to younger teens/older teens/ all teens/ no teens.
Author website: http://wendymass.com/
Reviewer: Cheri Blomquist
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
The Eye of Minds, by James Dashner (Mortality Doctrine series, Book 1)
*2014 YALSA Teens’ Top Ten Nominee; 2014 IRA Young Adults’ Choices*
Core Themes: cyberterrorism, friendship, sacrifice, overcoming obstacles
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: none
Violence/abuse: The first chapter opens with the suicide of a gamer; another chapter is somewhat
gruesome with war-like, hand-to-hand combat and killing in a virtual game setting. There are instances of
life and death situations, but they occur in a virtual setting.
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This book was my first foray into YA gaming fiction and it was probably a good starting
point for a novice in this genre. James Dashner's new hero is a teen named Michael who is a skilled gamer
and even more skilled hacker in the Virtual Reality world known as VirtNet. Michael, along with his two
friends, is recruited by the government to go off the VirtNet grid and find a hacker named Kaine who is
trapping gamers in the VirtNet and leaving their real bodies brain dead. Although the story is a bit slow at
the beginning, it does pick up significantly once Michael goes on the hunt for Kaine. This is a good tech/
sci-fi story, but I would have liked a little more development of the characters to make them more real and
to make me more invested in the story. One thing Dashner could have explained better was how Michael
became such a good hacker in the first place and how he "hacked." There are some descriptions of
looking at patterns in code and downloading some things, but the process was never really described
enough to capture my interest. Perhaps it would be too complex of a subject to delve into in a YA novel.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: Most of the story is fine for all teens with the exception of those who may be squeamish reading about the war-type fighting/combat virtual game. It doesn't last too long but there are a few gruesome sequences.
Author website: http://jamesdashner.com/
Reviewer: Annika Holland
*2014 YALSA Teens’ Top Ten Nominee; 2014 IRA Young Adults’ Choices*
Core Themes: cyberterrorism, friendship, sacrifice, overcoming obstacles
Drugs/alcohol: none
Religion/occult: none
Romance/sexuality: none
Violence/abuse: The first chapter opens with the suicide of a gamer; another chapter is somewhat
gruesome with war-like, hand-to-hand combat and killing in a virtual game setting. There are instances of
life and death situations, but they occur in a virtual setting.
Vulgarities: none
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This book was my first foray into YA gaming fiction and it was probably a good starting
point for a novice in this genre. James Dashner's new hero is a teen named Michael who is a skilled gamer
and even more skilled hacker in the Virtual Reality world known as VirtNet. Michael, along with his two
friends, is recruited by the government to go off the VirtNet grid and find a hacker named Kaine who is
trapping gamers in the VirtNet and leaving their real bodies brain dead. Although the story is a bit slow at
the beginning, it does pick up significantly once Michael goes on the hunt for Kaine. This is a good tech/
sci-fi story, but I would have liked a little more development of the characters to make them more real and
to make me more invested in the story. One thing Dashner could have explained better was how Michael
became such a good hacker in the first place and how he "hacked." There are some descriptions of
looking at patterns in code and downloading some things, but the process was never really described
enough to capture my interest. Perhaps it would be too complex of a subject to delve into in a YA novel.
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens. Note: Most of the story is fine for all teens with the exception of those who may be squeamish reading about the war-type fighting/combat virtual game. It doesn't last too long but there are a few gruesome sequences.
Author website: http://jamesdashner.com/
Reviewer: Annika Holland
See the content keys for an explanation of the numbers.
The Eye of Zoltar, by Jasper Fforde (Chronicles of Kazam, book 3)
Core themes: courage; friendship; sacrifice
Drugs/alcohol: an overdose of magical items (like overdosing on drugs)
Religion/occult: Magic is an important part of the stories. “Real magic is weird and mysterious, a fusion between science and faith.” “Life is magic, and magic is life.” It’s present in the world like the force of electricity and can be drawn from by wizards and witches to accomplish feats. Using magic in the books is akin to programming but something only a few people have the physical ability to do. (Jennifer Strange is not one of them; she can only use magic others have made.) Magic seems to prefer good to evil and works things out that way. In this book, there are angels who intercede to save people who have a role yet to play in the Grand Scheme of Things. There is also a comment that the real reason monasteries were closed was because they were running intensive angel farms. A main part of the story is the switching of the princess’s mind with that of a maid in the palace, which some religions (Catholicism, for one) would view as completely impossible as the “soul” and the “body” are inseparable.
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: There are magical beasts who attack and kill people, though not usually in a graphic or gory way. Jennifer leads a group of people on a quest that results in death for half of the people through various means (one is shot down by anti-aircraft guns, one is killed and stuffed by a tribe of “cannibalistic taxidermists,” and the like; again, many not graphic or gory). There are wars and battles that result in deaths. While most are not of the main characters, many are of friends or family members. Two members of the party sacrifice themselves to save the others.
Vulgarities: 1
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This book is witty and fun like the previous books in the series, though it ends in the middle of the series, so there is no happy ending (yet). The only possible objectionable material is the “magic” of the series, but this is obviously a fantasy world. Jennifer Strange is a “young lady of considerable daring, moral worth, and resourcefulness.”
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website:
For the series: http://www.jasperfforde.com/dragon/dragon.html
For the author: http://www.jasperfforde.com/index.html
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
Core themes: courage; friendship; sacrifice
Drugs/alcohol: an overdose of magical items (like overdosing on drugs)
Religion/occult: Magic is an important part of the stories. “Real magic is weird and mysterious, a fusion between science and faith.” “Life is magic, and magic is life.” It’s present in the world like the force of electricity and can be drawn from by wizards and witches to accomplish feats. Using magic in the books is akin to programming but something only a few people have the physical ability to do. (Jennifer Strange is not one of them; she can only use magic others have made.) Magic seems to prefer good to evil and works things out that way. In this book, there are angels who intercede to save people who have a role yet to play in the Grand Scheme of Things. There is also a comment that the real reason monasteries were closed was because they were running intensive angel farms. A main part of the story is the switching of the princess’s mind with that of a maid in the palace, which some religions (Catholicism, for one) would view as completely impossible as the “soul” and the “body” are inseparable.
Romance/sexuality: 1
Violence/abuse: There are magical beasts who attack and kill people, though not usually in a graphic or gory way. Jennifer leads a group of people on a quest that results in death for half of the people through various means (one is shot down by anti-aircraft guns, one is killed and stuffed by a tribe of “cannibalistic taxidermists,” and the like; again, many not graphic or gory). There are wars and battles that result in deaths. While most are not of the main characters, many are of friends or family members. Two members of the party sacrifice themselves to save the others.
Vulgarities: 1
Literary artistry: * * * * *
Comments: This book is witty and fun like the previous books in the series, though it ends in the middle of the series, so there is no happy ending (yet). The only possible objectionable material is the “magic” of the series, but this is obviously a fantasy world. Jennifer Strange is a “young lady of considerable daring, moral worth, and resourcefulness.”
I would suggest this book to: younger teens / older teens / all teens / no teens.
Author website:
For the series: http://www.jasperfforde.com/dragon/dragon.html
For the author: http://www.jasperfforde.com/index.html
Reviewer: Jill Papsdorf
